Report-4-6
pdf
School
University of Waterloo *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
4503
Subject
Finance
Date
Feb 20, 2024
Type
Pages
4
Uploaded by ChancellorIce13296
Deluxe corporation Executive summary KIRAN NAGARATNAM SKAND MITTAL
Frame the Key Issues and Decisions
Deluxe Corporation is the largest printer of paper cheques in the United States. Their core business has been experiencing a decline in sales revenue due to the growing maturity of the market for paper cheques in the United States coupled with a shift towards electronic forms of payments such as ATMs, credit cards, debit cards, and the Internet bill-paying systems. Taking on the role of Rajat Singh, the goal is to recommend an optimal capital structure for the corporation that will maximize shareholder value and aid in their share repurchasing attempts through a reliable WACC estimate. This recommendation must also factor in flexibility, bond rating, value creation, and Deluxe low costs, and continued access to capital. Recommending a financial policy that balances these goals is crucial to the financial sustainability of the firm. Alternatives
When computing the firm’s WACC, there are two viable alternatives to consider. The first alternative is to compute WACC using Bancorp’s estimates for Deluxe and the second a
lternative is to estimate the cost of equity using CAPM which will then replace Bancorp
’s
cost of equity estimate in the WACC computation. The debt ratios will be adjusted accordingly in each of the various scenarios. Under each alternative, the key elements of WACC must be scrutinized for their reliability and accuracy as the final WACC estimate plays a crucial role in determining the amount of debt to an issue, what grade of investment to maintain, and the final recommendation of the financial policy. Another set of alternatives to consider is whether to issue long-term financing or short-term financing. Some key considerations include their abilities to meet short-term debt obligations, the amount of access to short-term capital, and the cost of financing under both alternatives. This alternative will play an imperative role in Deluxe’s capital structure, WACC computation, and financial policy. Qualitative One of the main concerns for Rajat and the board of directors is optimizing the capital structure while retaining the current bond ratings while still managing to lower the cost of capital. According to the CEO, a good bond rating will not only save the interest payments but will also define D
eluxe’s brand value. Bond ratings are currently evaluated by third party rating agencies (Standard and Poor, M
oody’s in case of deluxe). This rating helps investors to understand a company’s liquidity position. Deluxe currently has an investment-grade bond rating of A. The financial team is looking to stay in this slot while maximizing the debt capacity to fund the working capital needs as the company is looking to make changes in its business model. What this essentially means is raising capital through debt to the point where the debt rating goes to BBB. This would ensure that the company still stays in an investment-grade bond slot. According to the projections performed by the analyst (exhibit 4), the sales are expected to grow annually by 0.2% due to the structural changes done recently by laying off employees and saving on fixed costs. This growth fuels working capital growth for the future. One of the other concerns is to avoid the debt overhang problem. Deluxe has a debt to value ratio of 33.97% which is in line with its brand value. Quantitative To fund its operations, Deluxe needs a total debt capacity of 960 million. This is calculated by dividing the interest implied of $55 million by the pre-tax cost of debt at the current A bond rating. The implied interest is calculated by dividing the expected EBIT by the target EBIT interest coverage. The required debt can be obtained by one of the two alternatives, short term or long-
term financing. Talking about the short-term financing options, Deluxe corporation has used a mix of commercial paper and line of credit to fund its operations in the past. However, short financing
is inadequate to fund the long-term plan of the company. The maximum funds from the short-term options add up to $850 million, $150 million from commercial paper, $300 million from medium-
term notes, and the rest from the committed and uncommitted line of credit. Furthermore, Deluxe
’s ability to meet their short-term obligation seems to below which is evident through their 2001 current ratio which is sitting at 0.23. The second alternative is using a long-term financing approach, there are two main calculations involved when it comes to long term financing option, the first being WACC calculation using Bancorp’s estimates. The WACC comes to 8.13% when using the Bancorp's pre-tax Kd and Ke at a 38% tax rate and an A bond rating estimates. Looking at the sensitivity analysis at A bond rating, we see quite a lot of fluctuations when it comes to changes in EBIT. Even though the WAC does not have significant changes from EBIT, the equity gains fluctuate significantly at different EBIT levels. The company even realizes a loss when the EBIT goes under 300 million. Therefore, the company needs to retain 350 million or higher EBIT to retain its gains. The second approach to WACC calculation involves the use of the CAPM model. This method gives a higher WACC of 12.5% at an A bond rating. This is because of a higher cost of equity for deluxe. This means that the WACC for Deluxe increases at a lower credit rating. This is because a lower rating comes with higher risk and therefore more returns for investors. This WACC is calculated using a market risk premium of 4.46% and an equity beta of 6.60%. One thing to note is that this WACC is calculated after the share repurchase has taken place and has therefore considered all aspects of a buyback. Another thing to note is that the changes in this WACC with a lower investment grade. The WACC increases to 9.5% and 10.4% at a BBB and BB rating. Recommendation
After conducting a thorough quantitative and qualitative analysis on each of the alternatives, we believe that Deluxe should pursue long-term financing and replace Bancorp’s cost of equity estimate with CAPM as it will provide a more accurate WACC estimate. As outlined above, Deluxe will run into problems with meeting short-term obligations and cannot draw enough capital from these sources to meet their financial policy. Furthermore, Bancorp’s cost of equity estimate is derived from Deluxe
’s
bond ratings and do not proportionately reflect the increased risk to equity from higher debt levels. Thus, computing the cost of equity through CAPM eliminates this error. Given that long-term financing is pursued and WACC is computed using CAPM Ke estimates, the optimal capital structure is attained at a debt/equity ratio of 51.44% or a debt-to-value ratio of approximately 34% as depicted in the exhibit 1. This capital structure will have the lowest cost of capital and will be within an A grade investment. It will also allow for ample flexibility depicted through the remaining debt capacity before the bond reaches non-investment grade, value creation through gain in equity from recapitalization, and maintaining invest grade securities. This recommendation balances the goals outlined in the opening paragraph and proves to be an effective policy. Assuming EBIT forecasts are accurate, a sound financial policy can easily be implemented, however, if EBIT deviates from projected forecasts significantly in a negative manner, there will be a plethora of financial implications for Deluxe. With EBIT at $200 000 when issuing investment-grade A debt, Deluxe will experience an increase in WACC and a loss to equity from recapitalization as depicted in the exhibit 4. This scenario may give rise to a debt-overhang problem as too much debt has been taken out relative to their EBIT and may cause a limitation in borrowing debt in the future and adhering to their financial policy. There lies uncertainty surrounding the forecast of EBIT which is a determining factor of their financial policy.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Exhibit 1: Exhibit 2: Exhibit 3: Exhibit 4: Exhibit 5:
Related Documents
Related Questions
Gregg’s Shipping Supplies Ltd (GSSL) trades in the buying and selling of ship spares and has several branches within the Caribbean. Recently the company has seen a rapid increase in demand of its products across all branches and is therefore in need of additional financing to adequately boost its supply inventory. The corporate banking head of Bankers Choice Bank is requesting a full set of financial statements to ensure that granting the loan to GSSL would be financially feasible during a period when many businesses are facing financial challenges. The company financial year ends on June 30 each year and you have been tasked with the responsibility to prepare the financial information for the St. Kitts branch.
1. Prepare the Adjusted Trial balance at June 30, 2022.
arrow_forward
The COVID-19 pandemic has affected one of your customers, NEST Ltd adversely. Even though the economies are fast recovering, they have contacted your company to request to purchase on credit instead of cash on delivery. Your boss, Alan, the Marketing Manager has instructed you to review their request. He has asked you to review NEST Ltd’s latest set of financial statements.
(a)In addition, identify other information(other than balance sheet, incomes statement and cash flow statement) that will be helpful in deciding whether to accede to NEST Ltd’s request?
(b)You have also noticed that compared to last year, the allowance for bad debt for Nest Ltd has increased from 2% to 4 % of the accounts receivable. Discuss how this information will impact your review.
arrow_forward
Case Study:
ABC Corporation is a medium-sized manufacturing company that produces consumer electronics. The company has a complex financial structure with multiple departments, a diverse range of products, and transactions occurring in various currencies due to its global operations. ABC Corporation recently experienced discrepancies in its financial statements, leading the management to investigate the root causes and improve its accounting processes.
The finance team identified that one of the major issues contributing to the discrepancies is a lack of proper reconciliation of bank statements. The company operates numerous bank accounts for various purposes, including payroll, supplier payments, and revenue collections. The manual reconciliation process has proven to be time-consuming and error-prone, resulting in inaccuracies in the financial records.
To address these challenges, ABC Corporation is considering implementing an automated bank reconciliation system that integrates with…
arrow_forward
Help
arrow_forward
Why Question#7's answer is "false"?
Provide your own answer?
arrow_forward
The birth of the Internet in the 1990s led to the creation of a new industry of online retailers
such as Amazon, Overstock.com, and PCM, Inc. Many of these companies often act as
intermediaries between the manufacturer and the customer without ever taking possession of
the merchandise sold. Revenue recognition for this type of transaction has been controversial.
Assume that Overstock.com sold you a product for $200 that cost $150. The company's profit
on the transaction clearly is $50. Should Overstock recognize $200 in revenue and $150 in
cost of goods sold (the gross method), or should it recognize only the $50 in gross profit (the
net method) as commission revenue? 4. Do you agree with Alphabet's reasoning with respect
to choosing whether it reports revenue gross versus net with respect to these advertising
services? Indicate "yes" or "no," and explain.
arrow_forward
The operation manager of Marcoba Bhd is seeking your advice on his company's request for a
computer software to be used in managing the sales of the company. He is unsure of how to
obtain the computer software but realizes that different types of acquisition will impact the
company's financial statement differently. He is considering the following possibilities: a)
Making a purchase of the computer software externally. The quotation that he has received
includes packages for payroll and general ledger. b) Making a purchase of a computer
software that can be incorporated into a sales system that the company will develop. c)
Signing a contract with independent programmers to develop a computer software that will
specifically cater for Marcoba Bhd's own use d) Employing own programmers to write a
computer software that the company will use. Required: Advice the operation manager on the
impact of each possibility above on the company's financial statement
arrow_forward
D’Leon Inc. is a snack food (bakery) company that underwent major expansion in 2018. Which of the following did NOT occur:
Group of answer choices
Suppliers are being paid late
Sales fell as the company cut prices and lost market share
Bank has threatened to cut off credit
Inventories increased
Company’s cash position weakened
arrow_forward
provide an example of a country that has been able to curb/ significantly reduce their corruption levels in modern history (i.e., the last 50-100 years). What factors contributed to the ability to accomplish this? How did this positive trend impact the country’s overall development, including its economic development?
arrow_forward
Case 1
ABC Company is a relatively small dry-cleaning operation that has a very steady level of business. Since the company hired a new employee, however, cash inflows have decreased and the amount of promotional coupon redemptions have increased dramatically. The owner of the company has been very impressed with this new employee, but has suspicions regarding her cashiering practices. When comparing cash sales to check and credit card sales, the owner noted that the coupon redemption rate was dramatically higher for cash sales. The owner does not want to wrongly accuse the employee if she is innocent, but does want to find out if fraud is occurring. The owner calls you as an expert on fraud and asks you to recommend a reliable way to gather evidence that could determine if fraud is occurring. 1. What are some possible investigative methods you could suggest?
arrow_forward
f In addition to the risk factor identified in the preceding question, another risk factor relating to misstatements arising from fraudulent financial reporting
is:
Multiple Choice
Earnings this year are lower than management had hoped.
Accounts payable are limited to commercial suppliers.
Sales are made to residential, commercial, and governmental purchasers.
The industry faces great technological changes in almost all of its products.
Untitled docume...pdf
Untitled docume....pdf
docx
Presentation se...pdf
Untitled docume...pdf
MacBook Air
arrow_forward
Your client, Corp. B, is a trading or distributor of home living product. Corp B import goods and sells them to its customers who are retail stores. In the current year, Corp. B's financial statements reported an increase in net income. The increase was driven by increased sales. Corp B's accounts receivable also increased rapidly. Corp B reportedly has many new customers.You are informed that there may be a fictitious revenue generated using fictitious customers. Corp B makes fictitious credit sales using bogus customers, and when receivables are due, management make kiting in order to look like the fictitious accounts receivable paid by their customer.
What kind of audit procedure will you use to examine for possible kiting?
arrow_forward
Your client, Corp. B, is a trading or distributor of home living product. Corp B import goods and sells them to its customers who are retail stores. In the current year, Corp. B's financial statements reported an increase in net income. The increase was driven by increased sales. Corp B's accounts receivable also increased rapidly. Corp B reportedly has many new customers.You are informed that there may be a fictitious revenue generated using fictitious customers. Corp B makes fictitious credit sales using bogus customers, and when receivables are due, management make kiting in order to look like the fictitious accounts receivable paid by their customer.
Question:a. Explain how the fraud scheme can be carried out by Corp B?b. What kind of audit procedure will you use to examine for possible kiting?
arrow_forward
LOCKBOX SYSTEM Fisher-Gardner Corporation (FGC) began operations 5 years ago as
a small firm serving customers in the Chicago area. However, its reputation and market area grew quickly. Today FGC has customers all over the United States. Despite its
broad customer base, FGC has maintained its headquarters in Chicago, and it keeps its
central billing system there. On average, it takes 7 days from the time customers mail in
payments until FGC can receive, process, and deposit them. FGC would like to set up a
lockbox collection system, which it estimates would reduce the time lag from customer
mailing to deposit by 2 days—bringing it down to 5 days. FGC receives an average of
$2,300,000 in payments per day.
a. How much free cash would FGC generate if it implemented the lockbox system?
Would this be a one-time cash flow or a recurring one, assuming the company ceases
to grow? How would growth affect your answer?
b. If FGC has an opportunity cost of 6%, how much is the lockbox system worth…
arrow_forward
Which statement is correct
A. Firms Cabot use lockboxes if they use cash concentration accounts.
B. Firms prefer to increase delay on disbursements.
C. Firms prefer to eliminate all types of float.
D. Firms open regional offices so their employees can pick up lockbox payments throughout the day.
E. The check clearing act for the 21st century is designed to reduce total collection time to one day.
arrow_forward
Read the situation about Apple and answer the “Question and Analysis” part
arrow_forward
Please help me with this, i can understand
arrow_forward
1. During the time frame that Intel was making exclusivity payments to Dell, Dell’s business model was being adversely affected by the increasingly competitive
nature of the PC industry. What responsibility, if any, do auditors have to analyze
a client’s business model? Do auditors have a responsibility to track and analyze key developments in a client’s industry? Defend your answers.
2. What ethical issues do exclusivity agreements such as that between Dell and Intel raise? Are there analogous ethical issues faced by audit firms and their clients? Explain.
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you

Cornerstones of Financial Accounting
Accounting
ISBN:9781337690881
Author:Jay Rich, Jeff Jones
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- Gregg’s Shipping Supplies Ltd (GSSL) trades in the buying and selling of ship spares and has several branches within the Caribbean. Recently the company has seen a rapid increase in demand of its products across all branches and is therefore in need of additional financing to adequately boost its supply inventory. The corporate banking head of Bankers Choice Bank is requesting a full set of financial statements to ensure that granting the loan to GSSL would be financially feasible during a period when many businesses are facing financial challenges. The company financial year ends on June 30 each year and you have been tasked with the responsibility to prepare the financial information for the St. Kitts branch. 1. Prepare the Adjusted Trial balance at June 30, 2022.arrow_forwardThe COVID-19 pandemic has affected one of your customers, NEST Ltd adversely. Even though the economies are fast recovering, they have contacted your company to request to purchase on credit instead of cash on delivery. Your boss, Alan, the Marketing Manager has instructed you to review their request. He has asked you to review NEST Ltd’s latest set of financial statements. (a)In addition, identify other information(other than balance sheet, incomes statement and cash flow statement) that will be helpful in deciding whether to accede to NEST Ltd’s request? (b)You have also noticed that compared to last year, the allowance for bad debt for Nest Ltd has increased from 2% to 4 % of the accounts receivable. Discuss how this information will impact your review.arrow_forwardCase Study: ABC Corporation is a medium-sized manufacturing company that produces consumer electronics. The company has a complex financial structure with multiple departments, a diverse range of products, and transactions occurring in various currencies due to its global operations. ABC Corporation recently experienced discrepancies in its financial statements, leading the management to investigate the root causes and improve its accounting processes. The finance team identified that one of the major issues contributing to the discrepancies is a lack of proper reconciliation of bank statements. The company operates numerous bank accounts for various purposes, including payroll, supplier payments, and revenue collections. The manual reconciliation process has proven to be time-consuming and error-prone, resulting in inaccuracies in the financial records. To address these challenges, ABC Corporation is considering implementing an automated bank reconciliation system that integrates with…arrow_forward
- Helparrow_forwardWhy Question#7's answer is "false"? Provide your own answer?arrow_forwardThe birth of the Internet in the 1990s led to the creation of a new industry of online retailers such as Amazon, Overstock.com, and PCM, Inc. Many of these companies often act as intermediaries between the manufacturer and the customer without ever taking possession of the merchandise sold. Revenue recognition for this type of transaction has been controversial. Assume that Overstock.com sold you a product for $200 that cost $150. The company's profit on the transaction clearly is $50. Should Overstock recognize $200 in revenue and $150 in cost of goods sold (the gross method), or should it recognize only the $50 in gross profit (the net method) as commission revenue? 4. Do you agree with Alphabet's reasoning with respect to choosing whether it reports revenue gross versus net with respect to these advertising services? Indicate "yes" or "no," and explain.arrow_forward
- The operation manager of Marcoba Bhd is seeking your advice on his company's request for a computer software to be used in managing the sales of the company. He is unsure of how to obtain the computer software but realizes that different types of acquisition will impact the company's financial statement differently. He is considering the following possibilities: a) Making a purchase of the computer software externally. The quotation that he has received includes packages for payroll and general ledger. b) Making a purchase of a computer software that can be incorporated into a sales system that the company will develop. c) Signing a contract with independent programmers to develop a computer software that will specifically cater for Marcoba Bhd's own use d) Employing own programmers to write a computer software that the company will use. Required: Advice the operation manager on the impact of each possibility above on the company's financial statementarrow_forwardD’Leon Inc. is a snack food (bakery) company that underwent major expansion in 2018. Which of the following did NOT occur: Group of answer choices Suppliers are being paid late Sales fell as the company cut prices and lost market share Bank has threatened to cut off credit Inventories increased Company’s cash position weakenedarrow_forwardprovide an example of a country that has been able to curb/ significantly reduce their corruption levels in modern history (i.e., the last 50-100 years). What factors contributed to the ability to accomplish this? How did this positive trend impact the country’s overall development, including its economic development?arrow_forward
- Case 1 ABC Company is a relatively small dry-cleaning operation that has a very steady level of business. Since the company hired a new employee, however, cash inflows have decreased and the amount of promotional coupon redemptions have increased dramatically. The owner of the company has been very impressed with this new employee, but has suspicions regarding her cashiering practices. When comparing cash sales to check and credit card sales, the owner noted that the coupon redemption rate was dramatically higher for cash sales. The owner does not want to wrongly accuse the employee if she is innocent, but does want to find out if fraud is occurring. The owner calls you as an expert on fraud and asks you to recommend a reliable way to gather evidence that could determine if fraud is occurring. 1. What are some possible investigative methods you could suggest?arrow_forwardf In addition to the risk factor identified in the preceding question, another risk factor relating to misstatements arising from fraudulent financial reporting is: Multiple Choice Earnings this year are lower than management had hoped. Accounts payable are limited to commercial suppliers. Sales are made to residential, commercial, and governmental purchasers. The industry faces great technological changes in almost all of its products. Untitled docume...pdf Untitled docume....pdf docx Presentation se...pdf Untitled docume...pdf MacBook Airarrow_forwardYour client, Corp. B, is a trading or distributor of home living product. Corp B import goods and sells them to its customers who are retail stores. In the current year, Corp. B's financial statements reported an increase in net income. The increase was driven by increased sales. Corp B's accounts receivable also increased rapidly. Corp B reportedly has many new customers.You are informed that there may be a fictitious revenue generated using fictitious customers. Corp B makes fictitious credit sales using bogus customers, and when receivables are due, management make kiting in order to look like the fictitious accounts receivable paid by their customer. What kind of audit procedure will you use to examine for possible kiting?arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Cornerstones of Financial AccountingAccountingISBN:9781337690881Author:Jay Rich, Jeff JonesPublisher:Cengage Learning

Cornerstones of Financial Accounting
Accounting
ISBN:9781337690881
Author:Jay Rich, Jeff Jones
Publisher:Cengage Learning