1. (79) GMO Crops on the African Continent
docx
School
University of the People *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1503
Subject
Geography
Date
Jan 9, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
4
Uploaded by JudgeBravery3423
GMO Crops on the African Continent
After reading through the following article:
Deressa, T., Pugliese, J., Kimenyi, M.S. (2014). Genetically Engineered Crops: Key to Climate Adaptation and Food Security in Africa. Brookings Institute.
Retrieved from:
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/africa-in-focus/2014/09/04/gen
etically-engineered-crops-key-to-climate-adaptation-and-food-
security-in-africa/
Choose a side, either for or against GMO in Africa. And I choose the AGAINST.
AGAINST
1.
List the reasons why and how GMO would weaken the African continent.
2.
Explain how the possible positive impacts of GMO, could quickly turn into a negative impact (if any).
3.
Describe one country in Africa that you think would least benefit from harvesting GMO products.
Reasons why GMOs could weaken the African continent:
1. Dependence on multinational corporations: Introducing GMOs in Africa could lead to increased dependence on multinational corporations that own the patents for genetically modified seeds. This could result in a loss of control over agricultural practices and a shift towards a profit-driven model that may not align with the needs and priorities of African farmers and communities.
2. Threat to biodiversity: GMO crops have the potential to negatively impact biodiversity by reducing the variety of native plant species. This reduction in biodiversity can have long-term ecological consequences, including the loss of genetic diversity and increased vulnerability to pests and diseases.
3. Socioeconomic inequality: The adoption of GMOs in Africa may exacerbate existing socioeconomic inequalities. Small-scale farmers, who make up a significant portion of the agricultural sector in Africa, may face challenges in accessing and affording genetically modified seeds and associated technologies. This can widen the gap between large-scale commercial farmers and smallholder farmers, leading to increased inequality in the agricultural sector.
While GMOs have the potential to offer certain positive impacts, it is important to recognize that these benefits can also have unintended negative consequences. Here are some ways in which the positive impacts of GMOs could turn into negative impacts:
1. Development of resistance: One of the main advantages of GMOs is their ability to resist pests, diseases, and herbicides. However, over time, pests and diseases can develop resistance to the genetically modified traits. This can render the GMO crops less effective and require the development of new genetically modified traits or increased use of chemical interventions. This can lead to a cycle of dependency on technological solutions and potentially harmful chemical inputs.
2. Environmental impact: GMOs that are engineered for herbicide tolerance often lead to increased herbicide use. While this may initially result in effective weed control, over time, it can lead to the emergence of herbicide-resistant weeds. This can necessitate the use of stronger and more harmful herbicides, causing environmental damage and potential health risks for farmers and nearby communities.
3. Genetic contamination: GMO crops can cross-pollinate with non-GMO crops or wild relatives,
leading to the spread of genetically modified traits beyond intended boundaries. This genetic contamination can have negative impacts on biodiversity, as well as on the livelihoods of farmers who rely on traditional or organic farming practices. It can also result in legal disputes and economic losses for farmers whose crops have been contaminated.
Overall, while GMOs may have potential positive impacts, it is crucial to consider the potential negative consequences and carefully assess the long-term sustainability and implications of their adoption. It is imperative to have transparent and inclusive discussions, involving all stakeholders, to ensure that the benefits of GMOs do not outweigh the potential risks and negative impacts on the environment, biodiversity, farmer livelihoods, and food systems.
One country in Africa that may face challenges in benefiting from GMO products is Ethiopia. Ethiopia has a diverse agricultural sector, with a significant portion of the population engaged in
small-scale farming. The country has a rich agricultural heritage and a wide variety of traditional
crop varieties that have been adapted to local environmental conditions. Ethiopia's agricultural practices are predominantly rain-fed, and farmers rely on traditional knowledge and practices to mitigate the challenges of climate variability and limited access to resources. In such a context, the introduction of GMO crops may pose several challenges:
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
1. Seed sovereignty: Ethiopia has a long history of seed saving and exchange, with farmers preserving and exchanging traditional seed varieties that are adapted to local conditions. The introduction of GMO crops may threaten this traditional seed system, as GMO seeds are often patented and controlled by multinational corporations. This could limit farmers' control over their own seeds and reduce their ability to adapt to changing environmental conditions.
2. Environmental concerns: Ethiopia has a diverse agro ecological landscape, and the introduction of GMO crops may have unintended consequences on biodiversity and ecosystem health. The potential risks associated with increased chemical inputs and genetic contamination
could negatively impact the country's rich biodiversity and traditional farming practices.
It is crucial to note that this assessment is a generalization and may not capture the specific circumstances and complexities of the Ethiopian agricultural sector. A comprehensive analysis conducted by experts and stakeholders would be required to determine which country in Africa
would least benefit from harvesting GMO products.
Reference
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/africa-in-focus/2014/09/04/
genetically-engineered-crops-key-to-climate-adaptation-and-food-
security-in-africa/
Word count: 833