Final Draft

.docx

School

Florida International University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

1101

Subject

Linguistics

Date

Apr 3, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

Uploaded by MateDove3948

David Neris 3/26/2023 ENC1101 The Complexities of African American Language: Synthesizing Perspectives on Linguistic Diversity in Society The issue of African American Language and its status in society is complex and multifaceted, and can be better understood through a synthesis of different perspectives. In the texts "If Black English Isn't a Language, Then What Is?" by James Baldwin, "African American Language is not Good English" by Jennifer M. Cunningham, and "Should Writers Use They Own English?" by Vershawn Ashanti Young, the authors acknowledge the existence of African American Language and highlight the importance of recognizing and respecting linguistic diversity. To introduce these texts, it is important to provide a summary of the content and their intended audience. Baldwin's text challenges the notion that African American Language is not a language, arguing that it has its own grammar, syntax, and vocabulary. Cunningham's text argues that African American Language is not inferior to Standard English, but is rather a legitimate language system with its own rules and conventions. Young's text addresses the issue of whether writers should use African American Language in their work, arguing that they should be able to use their own language and dialect without facing discrimination or ridicule. By reading these texts together, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities surrounding the status of African American Language in society and how it is perceived by different people. Through a synthesis of these different perspectives, we can begin to appreciate the importance of recognizing and respecting linguistic diversity in our society. Both Baldwin and Cunningham acknowledge the existence of AAL and argue for its legitimacy as a distinct language variety. Baldwin asserts that African American Language is a "language in every sense of the word" (170) and is a "complex and inventive" (169) system with its own rules and structures. Similarly, Cunningham recognizes African American Language as a "viable language system" (90) with its own grammar, pronunciation, and vocabulary. However, the authors differ in their views on the status of African American Language in society. Baldwin argues that it is a separate and equally valid language that has been stigmatized and devalued by the dominant culture. He contends that the rejection of African American Language is rooted in racism and a desire to maintain power and control over marginalized groups. On the other hand, Cunningham claims that African American Language is not "good English" but rather a deviation from Standard English. She argues that students should be taught Standard English in schools and that African American Language should only be used in certain contexts, such as informal settings or within the African American community. The disagreement between Baldwin and Cunningham highlights the complexities surrounding the status of African American Language in society and the need to recognize and respect linguistic diversity. While Baldwin emphasizes the importance of valuing and preserving African American Language as a distinct linguistic system, Cunningham stresses the need for students to learn and use Standard English in formal settings. Overall, the texts demonstrate the importance of acknowledging and embracing linguistic diversity in all its forms.

David Neris 3/26/2023 ENC1101 The importance of recognizing and respecting linguistic diversity in writing is a recurring theme in various texts. In his article "Should Writers Use They Own English?", Young argues that writers should embrace their own language varieties, including AAL, and resist the pressure to conform to Standard English. Young contends that instead, embracing linguistic diversity can help writers convey their unique experiences and perspectives more authentically. This view is supported by James Baldwin, who argues that "Language is a political instrument...It is the most vivid and crucial key to identify: it reveals the private identity, and connects one with, or divorces one from, the larger, public, or communal identity" (Baldwin). Baldwin's assertion that language reflects culture and identity underscores the importance of acknowledging and respecting linguistic diversity, both in writing and in everyday life. As Young points out, "we all should know everybody’s dialect, at least as many as we can, and be open to the mix of them in oral and written communication" (111). Recognizing and valuing linguistic diversity in writing and in society is critical for promoting inclusivity and respecting individual identity. Language diversity is a social and cultural reality that should not be ignored or suppressed in academic or professional settings. Instead, embracing linguistic diversity can create a more inclusive and equitable society that celebrates the unique experiences and perspectives of all individuals. The texts emphasized the need to embrace individual cultural and linguistic identities, rather than forcing conformity to a standardized form of English. These ideas are important for promoting inclusivity and creating a more equitable society that values diversity. Growing up as a Dominican in a predominantly white culture, I understand the challenges of adapting to linguistic norms that differ from those at home. It can be difficult to balance one's cultural identity with the pressure to conform to a standardized form of English. However, embracing linguistic diversity can be a source of strength in communication. The texts highlight the role of language in reflecting one's culture and identity, and the need to celebrate linguistic diversity. By recognizing and celebrating linguistic diversity, we can create a more compassionate community that embraces the unique experiences and perspectives of individuals. Recognizing and valuing linguistic diversity is crucial for promoting inclusivity and equity in a diverse society. By embracing individual cultural and linguistic identities, we can celebrate our uniqueness and enrich the world around us.

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help