Journal Week 5
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Liberty University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
600
Subject
Medicine
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
docx
Pages
4
Uploaded by jhumphrey26
This week’s discussion brought out a lot of opinions and perspectives in subject matters
that I was not well-versed in.
It gave me the opportunity to think critically about topics
that are affecting our world right now.
Especially the discussion on socialized medicine
considering the world climate we are presently in.
I would like to begin this week’s
journal entry discussing socialized medicine.
In our group discussion on of our group
members gave an extremely detailed outline regarding socialized medicine along with
his thoughts concerning it.
I found that to be so helpful as it was the prefect foundation
for the rest of our group’s discussion. As a group we all were of the opinion that we did
not want socialized medicine.
One of the main points we discussed in our group and so
it also in the class wide discussion was the idea of the government and its role in
socialized medicine.
The United States in some ways in already participating in forms of
free healthcare through programs such state prison healthcare, Medicare, military
medicine, Indian health services, and state funded free healthcare.
What sets these
services apart from a socialized medicine system is not all aspects of the process is
governed by one body.
In socialized medicine the government has complete control and
authority over every aspect of the healthcare system from funding down to the actual
facility.
The way this would be funded would be through taxes.
While I was reading up
on socialized medicine some of the literature was clear to make a distinction between
socialized medicine and universal medicine/healthcare.
Universal healthcare was
described as simply having access to healthcare but did not include the facilities,
providers, and hospitals.
In my opinion having a socialized medical system where the
government is solely responsible for everything is not wise and not fair to the taxpayers.
I also think there will be a loss of accountability in this kind of approach who is holding
the government accountable for the actions and policies with the authority to make
changes.
It quickly becomes a political mess in my opinion.
Another aspect of
socialized medicine to consider is how does this
affect healthcare professionals?
Will
they be properly compensated for the amount of time that have invested in their careers.
Beside the compensation will there be enough professionals to service everyone.
There
is also this idea of rationing that was brought up during our class discussion.
There is
no way to know if a sort of hierarchy system in determining who gets care first will arise.
One of my main concerns with this approach is how will the quality of care be affected.
Quality care doesn’t just refer to a healthcare professional being good or bad but their
ability to make decisions and provide customized care for their patients.
Physicians are
uniquely made to problem solve and would being under a socialized structure inhibit
them from using creative approaches.
In contrast to all the cons I have discussed above
I can understand why this approach seems appealing to some.
Healthcare is extremely
expensive and can be crippling to some especially if situations where you require more
than just the regular checkup.
I think there are other avenues to explore first to address
healthcare in our country that begins with looking to ways to adjust taxes for businesses
and make it more affordable for them to provide healthcare to their employees and
maybe even lower cost for healthy individuals that might not require as much traditional
healthcare as others.
I do know of some insurance companies that are taking a similar
approach the only caveat is when you get sick it gets very expensive very quickly.
Healthcare is absolutely an industry looking to not only tend to the physical needs but
also make money so maybe reform starts there in the place between helping and
making money.
The second question we addressed as a group was concerning prayer. Prescriptions,
and pastoral care.
I really liked these questions because it hits on something so real for
everyone.
Sometimes the cast studies we are discussing seem a little abstract and far
away but this question I think is applicable to everyone and everyone no matter their
background can speak to it.
My thoughts on the matter immediately start with a combo
approach.
I think that all of these things when working together can do some amazing
things.
Something that one has to consider when approaching this question is
perspective and more specifically the perspective of the patient who will come in a
variety of forms.
As a believer I completely support and incorporate prayer in my
professional and personal life.
I think that prayer and pastoral care coupled with
prescriptions is extremely important when treating individuals physically and mentally.
I
think we also have to consider this question in terms of our patient and what
environment we are talking about.
Obviously if we are in an environment that allows for
prayer and pastoral care integration
then absolutely as a believer, I think it is necessary.
I am a strong advocate in using medication when necessary because I think medicine
and doctors are truly gifts from God.
One of our group members mentioned in
discussion that even the secular world is interacting with some form of prayer or
meditation and have found a since of peace doing this.
In Matthew 17:20 it says
“You
don’t have enough faith,” Jesus told them. “I tell you the truth, if you had faith even as
small as a mustard seed, you could say to this mountain, ‘Move from here to there,’ and
it would move. Nothing would be impossible. (NLT). This to me exemplifies the
importance of prayer and the strength that comes with it.
In a clinical professional
setting, my religious beliefs have to take a back seat to treating the patient unless I an in
an environment where this acceptable.
I don’t ever want to push my faith on anyone
and attack their belief system.
This does not mean that a physician cant in private
prayer for his/hers patients or ask God for guidance when handling cases but it does
mean that we should not do anything that will make a patient uncomfortable.
Another
thought that was brought up during the class discussion and was directed at me
specifically concerning having a Muslim patient who wanted prayer and asked what my
approach would be if I was that patient.
The actual question was as follows:
what
would you do if you were a Muslim patient and needed pastor care, and the only pastor
in the hospital in Pentecostal being that you were admitted into a Pentecostal hospital?
Is it against your religion to accept prayers from outsiders of the religion? Do you accept
medication and treatment due to your religion?
This is how I responded: I am strong
believer in knowing and having a working knowledge of scripture. If the scenario that
you have presented, I have actually been able to experience as a friend of mind whose
parent was Muslim found herself on her death bed in a hospital with a chaplain service.
She in spite of her religion asked to see the chaplain and prayed with him. In moments
where an individual is wanting and asking for prayer then by all means provide them
with prayer and support. God and prayer is available to all if they want it. In regard to
treatment and medication this decision is left in the hands of the patient. I cannot speak
on behalf of a Muslim patient because I do not know all the ends and outs of their
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help