Assignment B: Ethical Case Analysis There are many stakeholders at Avco Environmental Services that will be affected in this scenario. Chantale is a stakeholder because she is a clerk at Avco and found documents that the company has been disposing of medical waste in the local municipal landfill. When Chantale became aware of this problem, she attempted to inform her supervisor, David, who expressed that it was none of their concern. She made an effort to go above her supervisor and went to talk to the company’s operations manager, Angela, who told her that the regulations were exaggerated and that there was no hazard or risk from the tiny amount of medical waste that the company sneaks into the municipal landfill and told her to drop it. Another …show more content…
Avco is acting in a right vs. wrong manner because they are getting rid of medical waste from hospitals which is necessary to keep hospitals clean. However, they are acting in a wrong manner because they are dumping the toxic medical waste in a municipal landfill instead of a special landfill in order to save money and gain a profit. Another ethical issue is that they are knowingly breaking the law set by the Environmental Protection Agency. The EPA has banned the disposing of toxic waste in ordinary landfills, for which they have special landfills to get rid of such waste. Now, that Chantale is aware of this issue, if she does not say or do anything to make this issue be addressed, she is just as guilty as the company managers even if she has no influence. Avco lacks Corporate Social Responsibility and only caring about giving shareholders more profit. The last ethical issue is that public health is being compromised and people are unaware that it is happening in their community. According to Eckardt Beck, author of the article The Love Canal Tragedy, there is nothing wrong with disposing hazardous waste in landfills as long as they are “properly sited, managed, and
1. What were the costs and benefits to stakeholders of the actions taken by Massey Energy and its managers?
From the beginning of time, there has always been wildlife. The animals and plants of our wildlife contribute to what makes this life so interesting. If all wildlife were to go extinct, then we would not have a way to replenish the oxygen to survive off of. All animals and plants are a part of our lifecycle and should be respected as such.
In the introduction of Andrew Light and Holmes Rolston’s book , Environmental Ethics: An Anthology, the authors explain the basic concepts of ethics: more specifically environmental ethics, and how they apply to everyday life. The main concepts discussed include moral agents, moral patients, anthropocentrism, weak or broad anthropocentrism, indirectly morally considerable, and directly morally considerable. These concepts are the foundations to the environmental ethics that Light and Rolston wrote about; however, in regards to the short story written by J. Lanham titled: “Hope and Feathers: A crisis in birder identification,” the two terms most predominately relating to the text are moral patients and moral agents. Lanham, in this text, describes the epitome of what it means to be a good moral agent, as interpreted by Light and Rolston, where others failed.
Robbins Elementary, an urban school located in a large city in Texas, has defied the odds by attaining and sustaining high academic success rates for an approximate twenty-year time period. As Okilwa and Barnett (2017) noted, Robbins Elementary had grown to become homogeneous in race (majority Hispanic) and economic status (increased economically disadvantaged status). According to the article (Okilwa & Barnett, 2017), 2013 census data revealed that 50% of families in Robbins Elementary attendance zone earned less than $35,000 annually, with a median income of $35,282. Assumptions regarding high-need schools would, undoubtedly, portray Robbins Elementary as a school that would struggle academically with high teacher and principal
This is the first issue that proves to be unethical. The company lies to the residents in the area about contamination by hexavalent chromium. This is unethical because the company had the specific intention of lying to the residents in order to keep their company running. The company knew that it would suffer if the truth came out about the contamination. Since they lied about the hexavalent chromium, most of the residents suffered from illness due to contaminated water. The company then was involved in another unethical act as they offered to provide initial medical exams, so that they could easily hide the truth that the illnesses came from the contamination. As a result from the many health issues residents received, a great deal of money was spent on doctors visits and care. As the company tried to hide the contamination issues, they ultimately caused the sickness of the surrounding individuals. Pacific Gas &Electric Company is responsible for lying and deceiving, as well as knowingly letting residents suffer from illness. They intentionally risked the well being of the community that surrounds the corporation, so that their business could still
Frank is the manager of corporate reporting at Amalgamated Forests Products. He had objected to the report "Endangered Species: The Pulp and Paper Industry in the Upper Peninsula', this report contained the industry's response to the new government's proposals to control effluents from being discharged into environmentally sensitive regions. Amalgamated Forests Products had taken a lead in presenting the perspective of the five pulp and paper companies in the region. Frank believed the report that was prepared was inaccurate and deceitful.
each issue. To do so, arguments should explicitly draw upon the theories outlined in class –
Traditionally, Western views of environment ethics has been unclear and for the most part unnecessary. We used earth’s resources without thinking about consequence. This nonchalant use aided in the West’s ability to influence the world through technological advances. In the past, limited travel and slow communication systems had limited our view to a local one. If pollution or to much urbanization occurred the solution was to move.
There are various ethical and financial issues being discussed in the current scenario and these issues are elaborated as:
As a manager of a fine dining restaurant in an inner city suburb, I notice that there is an increase in the number of people enquiring about food items featured on the menu. Some are vegetarian; some ask where and how the food is produced, whilst others are celiac or show a high level of concern over the ingredients used in each dish, due to allergies. As a result, there will be a growing trend towards consuming foods based on informed choice.
The main way that the city of Detroit was able to ensure ethical conduct was by making an example of Kwame Kilpatrick. According to US Attorney McQuade, “This case is not so much about punishing for the past as it about shaping the future. These sentences will deter other officials from stealing from the people and will attract honest public servants to office” (State News Service, 17 October 2013). This is falls under the philosophical theory of libertarianism in that justice is necessary for not only the public to heal, but also to serve as a deterrent to other public officials thinking of following a similar path. Another method is unusual and can only be enacted by the governor of the
The success of Company X is largely determined by the ethical actions and integrity of the employees that support Company X. We are committed to providing education and dialog to promptly address ethical questions or concerns raised by an employee. Managers should encourage discussion amongst employees especially regarding ethics. Ethics dialog should become integrated into a normal work day to keep ethics fresh on everyone’s minds and allow for manager and peer coaching. Ethical dilemmas can occur at any level of business and all employees should be able to make a decision that properly reflects the values and integrity of Company X. We must strive that every action at Company X promotes
The firm Hodo is planning to expand their new plants “Ultramodern” in an area. However, the firm is not majorly concerned about implementing industry standard waster treatment for the plant in which they assume it as being costly. It is lower for federal standars, but there are other organisations that petition it to be higher. John then is having doubts whether he should really continue working for the company with weak standards when it comes to the environment. From the summarised case, we can already imply several ethical issues or dilemmas faced within the company that are ought to be amended.
Since I was in second grade, I have had a passion for preserving the environment. I am always looking for more ways that I can share my excitement with my community. So, when I entered high school, I joined the Environmental Club to work with other students who are passionate about environmental preservation. When I joined, it was a group of five students who would collect and sort the school's recyclables. With over 2,500 students and faculty members, this is like recycling for a small community, and while recycling is extremely important, I wanted to make an even larger impact on my community.
For this week Unit 7 written assignment, I choose to talk about Voluntary euthanasia. A brief history and ethical and unethical dilemma of this topic will also be looked into in this assignment.