preview

Hawthorne Effect

Decent Essays

Management has played a key role in business for many many years. Throughout this time management has evolved and improved vastly. Many new theories have been discovered and implemented within the workplace to improve workers effectiveness and affiance which then inturn increases productivity for the business. Throughout the late 1940’s research by the theorists was focused on Behavioural Management, which is the study of how managers should behave to encourage and motivate employees to perform at high levels and to be committed to the achievement of organisational goals.(Waddle, Devine , Jones and George 2007, pp52) . Various theorist had their own views on how management should behave towards it their workers. Two of the most famous …show more content…

Researchers claim that with or without a wage incentive the productivity levels continued to rise. If assumptions were to be made on statistics alone the fact that workers continued to work harder and more efficient despite the working conditions shows that incentives were not the reason for the improvements. Even when working conditions were made to be miserable i.e. Longer days or fewer rest breaks the workers still continued to improve. That raised the questions, if incentives and better working conditions are not the reason behind the increased production then what is? An explanation put forward by Elmes, Kantowitz, and Roediger was that because the workers knew that the experimenters were watching them and expected them to change their production levels they did.( Was there a Hawthorne Effect? Stephen R.G. Jones, The American Journal of Sociology, Vol 98 No 3( Nov 1992), pp 453) This assumption then supports the statement that yes in actual fact there was a Hawthorn Effect because due to the Hawthorn studies changes had occurred within the work place relating to production which would then be deemed as an affect. There are also arguments against the notion that there was a Hawthorne Affect with Stephan Jones saying that “ I have found essentially no evidence of Hawthorne effects, either unconditionally or with allowances for direct effects of the experimental variables themselves.”(Brannigan, A &Zwerman, ‘The Real

Get Access