preview

Text Analysis Response

Decent Essays

The following samples are from my first year of teaching.

Section 1: The first two worksheets were used as a guide to get students prepared for a Text Analysis Response. The first sample is from a student with an IEP, the second is from a General Education student.

Pros
Directions are clear
Model is provided
Worksheet aligns with learning target and directly correlates with the Text Analysis Response

Areas for Improvement
The feedback provided was not effective. Feedback given did not state what the student did well and areas for improvement. I didn't even attempt to get the student to question their thinking through questioning. For an example, with student one I could have asked to reflect on what kind of mood is evoked by illustrating a landscape that has only two homes on a road. In addition, I should have also asked if quote four was the best example of setting to analyze. For …show more content…

These students will reappear later on to show their growth in writing text analysis responses.

Pros
Guided students with questions to think about as they read
Provided vocabulary

Areas for Improvement
Didn't grade students work using a rubric where they can see what they got for each criteria
Feedback was not purposeful

Section 3: The next two sections are artifacts (for an Argumentative Essay) from two different students (one student that reads below grade level, another that reads at grade level).

Artifact 1: “Rosendo’s Tale” with vocabulary sheet and guided questions (to be done in pairs while doing reciprocal reading) Artifact 2+3: First draft of student’s essay (section by section) with peer feedback Artifact 4: Final argumentative essay, rubric, and draft

Pros
Argumentative essay was scaffold
Peer feedback
Rubric used was the same as the Regents
Students had an opportunity to write a rough draft and see the grade they would have received Areas for

Get Access