preview

V For Vendetta Argumentative Essay

Decent Essays

V for Vendetta Argumentative Essay

Should batman kill the joker?
The joker has killed so many people and is going to kill more in the future, so why hasn’t batman killed him already? Well the answer is; though killing the joker would save many innocent lives, according to deontology, “…it may not be morally right for any person to kill him” (C, pp.8). So now on to the actual question; is V from V for Vendetta a hero or vigilante? The definition of “vigilante” is someone who takes the law into their own hands, often with violence and lacking lawful procedures. Let’s pretend V is batman and the Norsefire government of London is the joker. V is literally destroying the government while batman is trying to save as many lives as he can without destroying the joker. This is why batman is considered a hero. We could probably all agree first of all that the …show more content…

“Vigilantism is not always the KKK perpetrating a racist lynching in the dark of night,” in fact it’s the complete opposite in V’s case (B, pp.11). The KKK and Nazis are actual terrorist groups that target minorities. V was sent to Lark hill because he was a minority, how would it make any sense for V to target one of his own? In source B it says, “A further source of damage comes […] then further undermine the system's reputation and its crime-control effectiveness in a downward spiral to greater tragedy.” Though “undermining the systems reputation” is bad, it shouldn’t have to be undermined in the first place. V is trying to “[protect] privacy, [limit] governmental intrusion in citizens’ lives, and [maintain] a proper separation of powers” (B, pp.9). If the solution to do all this is to undermine the government, then so be it. No matter the procedures that have to be taken, whether it be killing or blowing up the house of parliament, the justification to freedom is

Get Access