Lindamood_Market Concentration in the Airline Industry
.pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
ECON 210
Subject
Economics
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
Pages
13
Uploaded by AdmiralDog4154
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Research Paper, Final Draft Greg Lindamood College of Business, Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University ECON 210 Microeconomics Professor Marlo Chavarria May 15, 2023
Market Concentration and Mergers in the Airline Industry Airline mergers have become increasingly common in the airline industry. An airline merger occurs when two or more airlines combine into a single entity. These mergers can be horizontal, where airlines of similar size and business models merge, or vertical, where airlines of different stages of the supply chain merge. The airline industry is highly competitive, with airlines constantly seeking ways to differentiate themselves from their rivals. Pricing strategies are a crucial component of this competition, with airlines using various methods to set prices in response to market conditions. This paper aims to explore the impact of airline mergers on competition, pricing strategies in the airline industry, and measures that can be taken to ensure fair competition and prevent market power abuse. Literature Review The airline industry is a significant contributor to the global economy, generating over $700 billion in revenue in 2019. However, it is a highly competitive and volatile industry, with airlines constantly seeking ways to differentiate themselves from their rivals. Pricing strategies are a crucial component of this competition, with airlines using various methods to set prices in response to market conditions. The airline industry is characterized by an oligopolistic market structure, with a small number of large firms dominating the market. This market structure makes the industry particularly susceptible to market power abuse, which can harm consumers and reduce competition.
One of the most significant developments in the airline industry in recent years has been the increasing trend toward airline mergers. These mergers can be horizontal, where airlines of similar size and business models merge, or vertical, where airlines of different stages of the supply chain merge. While airline mergers can lead to increased efficiencies and lower costs for consumers, they can also lead to reduced competition and higher prices. Economic Analysis The impact of airline mergers on competition and pricing strategies in the airline industry can be analyzed using the tools developed in microeconomics. Graphical analysis can be used to demonstrate how changes in market structure can affect market outcomes such as prices and quantities. For example, a merger between two airlines can lead to increased market concentration, resulting in higher prices and reduced consumer welfare. The following graph illustrates the impact of a merger on market concentration in Chinese Airline mergers: Figure 1: ⡥
ICAO (2022)
As shown in the graph, a merger between the airlines can result in a significant increase in market concentration, and can also be measured by the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI). An increase in market concentration can lead to reduced competition, resulting in higher prices and lower output. However, a merger can also lead to increased efficiencies, resulting in lower costs and prices for consumers. The following graph illustrates the impact of a merger on costs: Figure 2: ⡥
ICAO (2020) As shown in the graph, a merger can result in lower costs for the merged airline, as a result of increased efficiencies such as economies of scale. Lower costs can result in lower prices for consumers, leading to increased consumer welfare. Covid 19 Impact on Airline Mergers in the Industry The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on the airline industry, including mergers and acquisitions (ICAO, 2022). Before the pandemic, there was a trend toward consolidation in the industry, with several major mergers taking place in recent years. However, the pandemic has caused a sharp decline in air travel demand, leading to significant financial losses for airlines (ACI, 2020).
According to ACI (2020), “As reported in Forbes magazine, a consumer confidence survey conducted by IATA found that only 14% of passengers said they would fly right away. (…) National governments will likely progress gradually from permitting non-essential domestic travel and reviewing advice against international travel towards coordinated reciprocal arrangements to reassure smooth flow of passengers in both directions, as illustrated below.” Figure 3: © ACI (2020) As a result, many airlines are now focused on survival and recovery, rather than mergers and acquisitions. The financial uncertainty and volatility in the industry have made it difficult for airlines to pursue mergers or acquisitions, as it is unclear what the long-term financial outlook will be. Additionally, the pandemic has created new challenges for airlines, such as navigating travel restrictions and changing consumer preferences. As a result, many airlines are focused on adapting their business models and operations to the new normal, rather than pursuing mergers or acquisitions.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
Economists believe mergers can sometimes achieve greater efficiency than two companies that do not merge. true or false
arrow_forward
J
Copyright © McGraw-Hill Education. Permission is granted to reproduce for classroom use.
NAME
DATE
CLASS
Math Practice for Economics
Comparing Prices among Competitors
networks
Background information: The candy industry in the United States could be defined as an oligopoly
because just three companies make 99.4% of snack size chocolates. The big three companies are
Hershey's, Mars, and Nestle. All three companies use much of the same ingredients, so how do they
compete against one another? This is primarily done through price.
Directions: The two tables below show what a snack size chocolate costs from the various candy
makers, big and small. Read the table below. Then, answer the following questions using the
information in the table.
110 ct bag $18.12
= 16 cents each
Walmart
Amazon
Hershey's
215 ct. bag $13.88
= 6 cents each
100 ct. bag $12.81
= 13 cents each
Mars
230 ct. bag $13.88
= 6 cents each
Nestle
70 ct. bag $8.98
= 13 cents each
55 pc. Bag $17.96
= 33 cents each
Candy…
arrow_forward
Assume that Starbucks and Gloria Jeans are offering coffees with slightly different taste and acidity.
Assume that Starbucks and Gloria Jeans decided to merge. What type of merger will that be? Describe briefly using words. Will a merger be beneficial for the firms? Discuss briefly using words. DO NOT draw graphs. DO NOT do any calculations
arrow_forward
This assignment is designed to develop skills in collecting and assessing market information and presenting clear written communication about how market structure affects the conduct and performance of firms in an industry.
Select one of the three oligopoly markets in Singapore:
Telecommunications
Supermarkets
Ride-Hailing apps
Your assignment should address the following questions:
1.
2.
3.
How does the market structure (number of firms that compete in a market & relative size of the firms) affect the conduct or behaviour of firms in your chosen industry (price markups & amount spent on advertising) and their performance (profits)?
Using one or more Oligopoly models (Sweezy, Cournot, Stackelberg, Bertrand), analyse how firms in your chosen industry make and respond to their competitors' output and pricing decisions.
What are the pricing strategies (2nd degree, 3rd degree, Versioning, Bundling, Tying) that firms in your chosen industry implement, and discuss how…
arrow_forward
Companies are price takers under:
Oligopoly
Monopoly
Monopolistic competition
Perfect completion
The North West and Delta airlines merger is an example of a :
Horizontal merger
Vertical merger
Conglomerate merger
Diagonal merge
arrow_forward
Categorize each of the following examples as a horizontal, vertical, or conglomerate merger.
arrow_forward
Answer the following questions based on the information given in the article below.
MXCC to Probe Grab-Uber Merger
By Sulhi Azman, The Edge Markets, July 13,2018
KUALA LUMPUR (July 13): The Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC) will
investigate the merger between Uber and Grab in Malaysia, which has resulted in Grab
having a monopoly in the country's ride-hailing business.
"MyCC has taken preliminary action and conducted its first discussion with Uber and Grab
on March 30, 2018, which was four days after the two companies announced their merger
position," the Domestic Trade and Consumerism Ministry said in a statement today. Under
the Competition Act 2010, the ministry said MyCC is empowered to take on parties which
have merged and thus having resulted in a monopoly status within the market it operates at.
At the same time, the ministry said MyCC is empowered to investigate and take action on
parties abusing the monopoly status and violating Section 2 of the Competition Act 2010,…
arrow_forward
Question 14
An oligopoly is a market structure, dominated by more firms than a monopolistic structure.
False
True
arrow_forward
Merger of beer giants faces obstacles
Mega-brand beers have lost market share to wine and craft beer. In response, Anheuser-Busch InBev and SABMiller, the two biggest brewers in the world, are discussing a merger that would be scrutinized by antitrust regulators.
Source: The New York Times, September 16, 2015
How would a merger benefit the two big brewers? Under what circumstances would the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) challenge the merger?
A merger would benefit the two big brewers because
O A. the price of beer would fall close to the price in a perfectly competitive market and sales would increase
O B. average total cost would increase but price would increase by more than average total cost
O C. the price of beer could rise close to the monopoly price and economic profit would increase
O D. many craft brewers would be forced out of the market
The Federal Trade Commission would challenge the merger if
O A. it increases the HHI
O B. the HHI is less than 1,500
O C. the HHI is…
arrow_forward
Market Structure Analysis
1) Market Structure Identification - Samsung operates in an oligopoly with few dominant players in the electronics market, displaying interdependence. Describe more about it and provide evidence and reasons for classifying the company which is Samsung under the market structure of oligopoly.
2) Characteristics Analysis - for company Samsung, analyze and discuss the charateristics associated with oligopoly market structure. Consider factors such as the number of competitors, product differentiation, barriers to entry, pricing power, and market share. 3) Consumer Impact - evalute the impact of the oligopoly market structure on consumers of company Samsung. Discuss how pricing, product variety, and consumer welfare are affected in each case.
arrow_forward
Which of the following is the BEST example of a firm operating in an oligopoly market?
Group of answer choices
a coffee farmer in Costa Rica
Denny’s, a popular diner serving breakfast
PacSun, a clothing retailer
AB InBev, one of the three largest beverage companies in the world
arrow_forward
(REAL-WORLD APPLICATION) You are NOT required to read the oligopoly chapter in the textbook, but
you already know quite a lot about it from our discussion of strategic interactions using game theory
in weeks 2-3. This market structure is between monopoly and monopolistic competition, with only a
handful of firms having a high degree of market power. Let's refresh your memory with the following
example. Assume that the Australian low-cost airline industry consists of two firms and their situation can
be represented by the following payoff matrix.
Tigar Air
Nothing
Low Price
More Advertising
0, 16
6, 6
Nothing
10, 10
2, 14
Jetstar
Low Price
16, 0
12, 4
More Advertising
14, 2
4, 12
8, 8
a. Before solving the game, put yourself in the position of Jetstar and write down your action. Then
independent of that, put yourself in the position of Tiger Air and write down your action.
b. State all the dominated strategies in the full game, by which strategy they are dominated, and
whether weakly or…
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Managerial Economics: Applications, Strategies an...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506381
Author:James R. McGuigan, R. Charles Moyer, Frederick H.deB. Harris
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Exploring Economics
Economics
ISBN:9781544336329
Author:Robert L. Sexton
Publisher:SAGE Publications, Inc
Microeconomics: Principles & Policy
Economics
ISBN:9781337794992
Author:William J. Baumol, Alan S. Blinder, John L. Solow
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- Economists believe mergers can sometimes achieve greater efficiency than two companies that do not merge. true or falsearrow_forwardJ Copyright © McGraw-Hill Education. Permission is granted to reproduce for classroom use. NAME DATE CLASS Math Practice for Economics Comparing Prices among Competitors networks Background information: The candy industry in the United States could be defined as an oligopoly because just three companies make 99.4% of snack size chocolates. The big three companies are Hershey's, Mars, and Nestle. All three companies use much of the same ingredients, so how do they compete against one another? This is primarily done through price. Directions: The two tables below show what a snack size chocolate costs from the various candy makers, big and small. Read the table below. Then, answer the following questions using the information in the table. 110 ct bag $18.12 = 16 cents each Walmart Amazon Hershey's 215 ct. bag $13.88 = 6 cents each 100 ct. bag $12.81 = 13 cents each Mars 230 ct. bag $13.88 = 6 cents each Nestle 70 ct. bag $8.98 = 13 cents each 55 pc. Bag $17.96 = 33 cents each Candy…arrow_forwardAssume that Starbucks and Gloria Jeans are offering coffees with slightly different taste and acidity. Assume that Starbucks and Gloria Jeans decided to merge. What type of merger will that be? Describe briefly using words. Will a merger be beneficial for the firms? Discuss briefly using words. DO NOT draw graphs. DO NOT do any calculationsarrow_forward
- This assignment is designed to develop skills in collecting and assessing market information and presenting clear written communication about how market structure affects the conduct and performance of firms in an industry. Select one of the three oligopoly markets in Singapore: Telecommunications Supermarkets Ride-Hailing apps Your assignment should address the following questions: 1. 2. 3. How does the market structure (number of firms that compete in a market & relative size of the firms) affect the conduct or behaviour of firms in your chosen industry (price markups & amount spent on advertising) and their performance (profits)? Using one or more Oligopoly models (Sweezy, Cournot, Stackelberg, Bertrand), analyse how firms in your chosen industry make and respond to their competitors' output and pricing decisions. What are the pricing strategies (2nd degree, 3rd degree, Versioning, Bundling, Tying) that firms in your chosen industry implement, and discuss how…arrow_forwardCompanies are price takers under: Oligopoly Monopoly Monopolistic competition Perfect completion The North West and Delta airlines merger is an example of a : Horizontal merger Vertical merger Conglomerate merger Diagonal mergearrow_forwardCategorize each of the following examples as a horizontal, vertical, or conglomerate merger.arrow_forward
- Answer the following questions based on the information given in the article below. MXCC to Probe Grab-Uber Merger By Sulhi Azman, The Edge Markets, July 13,2018 KUALA LUMPUR (July 13): The Malaysia Competition Commission (MyCC) will investigate the merger between Uber and Grab in Malaysia, which has resulted in Grab having a monopoly in the country's ride-hailing business. "MyCC has taken preliminary action and conducted its first discussion with Uber and Grab on March 30, 2018, which was four days after the two companies announced their merger position," the Domestic Trade and Consumerism Ministry said in a statement today. Under the Competition Act 2010, the ministry said MyCC is empowered to take on parties which have merged and thus having resulted in a monopoly status within the market it operates at. At the same time, the ministry said MyCC is empowered to investigate and take action on parties abusing the monopoly status and violating Section 2 of the Competition Act 2010,…arrow_forwardQuestion 14 An oligopoly is a market structure, dominated by more firms than a monopolistic structure. False Truearrow_forwardMerger of beer giants faces obstacles Mega-brand beers have lost market share to wine and craft beer. In response, Anheuser-Busch InBev and SABMiller, the two biggest brewers in the world, are discussing a merger that would be scrutinized by antitrust regulators. Source: The New York Times, September 16, 2015 How would a merger benefit the two big brewers? Under what circumstances would the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) challenge the merger? A merger would benefit the two big brewers because O A. the price of beer would fall close to the price in a perfectly competitive market and sales would increase O B. average total cost would increase but price would increase by more than average total cost O C. the price of beer could rise close to the monopoly price and economic profit would increase O D. many craft brewers would be forced out of the market The Federal Trade Commission would challenge the merger if O A. it increases the HHI O B. the HHI is less than 1,500 O C. the HHI is…arrow_forward
- Market Structure Analysis 1) Market Structure Identification - Samsung operates in an oligopoly with few dominant players in the electronics market, displaying interdependence. Describe more about it and provide evidence and reasons for classifying the company which is Samsung under the market structure of oligopoly. 2) Characteristics Analysis - for company Samsung, analyze and discuss the charateristics associated with oligopoly market structure. Consider factors such as the number of competitors, product differentiation, barriers to entry, pricing power, and market share. 3) Consumer Impact - evalute the impact of the oligopoly market structure on consumers of company Samsung. Discuss how pricing, product variety, and consumer welfare are affected in each case.arrow_forwardWhich of the following is the BEST example of a firm operating in an oligopoly market? Group of answer choices a coffee farmer in Costa Rica Denny’s, a popular diner serving breakfast PacSun, a clothing retailer AB InBev, one of the three largest beverage companies in the worldarrow_forward(REAL-WORLD APPLICATION) You are NOT required to read the oligopoly chapter in the textbook, but you already know quite a lot about it from our discussion of strategic interactions using game theory in weeks 2-3. This market structure is between monopoly and monopolistic competition, with only a handful of firms having a high degree of market power. Let's refresh your memory with the following example. Assume that the Australian low-cost airline industry consists of two firms and their situation can be represented by the following payoff matrix. Tigar Air Nothing Low Price More Advertising 0, 16 6, 6 Nothing 10, 10 2, 14 Jetstar Low Price 16, 0 12, 4 More Advertising 14, 2 4, 12 8, 8 a. Before solving the game, put yourself in the position of Jetstar and write down your action. Then independent of that, put yourself in the position of Tiger Air and write down your action. b. State all the dominated strategies in the full game, by which strategy they are dominated, and whether weakly or…arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Managerial Economics: Applications, Strategies an...EconomicsISBN:9781305506381Author:James R. McGuigan, R. Charles Moyer, Frederick H.deB. HarrisPublisher:Cengage LearningExploring EconomicsEconomicsISBN:9781544336329Author:Robert L. SextonPublisher:SAGE Publications, IncMicroeconomics: Principles & PolicyEconomicsISBN:9781337794992Author:William J. Baumol, Alan S. Blinder, John L. SolowPublisher:Cengage Learning
Managerial Economics: Applications, Strategies an...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506381
Author:James R. McGuigan, R. Charles Moyer, Frederick H.deB. Harris
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Exploring Economics
Economics
ISBN:9781544336329
Author:Robert L. Sexton
Publisher:SAGE Publications, Inc
Microeconomics: Principles & Policy
Economics
ISBN:9781337794992
Author:William J. Baumol, Alan S. Blinder, John L. Solow
Publisher:Cengage Learning