Case 1 Economic at Buick-D-2023-v9 (5)
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Case Western Reserve University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
352
Subject
English
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
docx
Pages
12
Uploaded by GrandLemurPerson347
EECS 352: Eng. Economics
Term Project Case Study Professor Malakooti
EECS 352 – Engineering Economics and Decision Analysis
A-17- Revised 11/1/23-Type D
Professor Malakooti
Case Study Term Project General Instructions (25% of Total Grade)
Submit Word-file to Canvas with Embedded Excel Objects
This project must be done by each student. Any copying from any other source will
result in getting an F in this course and other severe penalties.
Please respond to all questions.
The Report for Each Model and Each Question of the Case Study
It is important to write a good report, in particular state your problem very clearly and
give a brief background and rational of the problem. Describe the development of your
model/solution step-by-step, along with any assumption you make. Display the results in
suitable forms and discuss your analysis of results along with your conclusions and
recommendations.
Answer the questions posed and follow the hints and suggestions given.
The final report should be prepared promptly. It should consist of the following sections
and details:
Introduction---provide a brief background of the case, and present a crisp
problem statement and the objective of the study—what questions you are
trying to answer? For what purpose? And so on.
A. Solution Strategy from Engineering Economics point of view:—describe
the approach you are using to carry out and organize your study and the
assumptions you are making (make these very clear). You will most likely
develop/adopt a cash flow model—show in some reasonable detail how the
individual cash flows are generated and integrated.
B. Solution Strategy from Decision Making and Risk point of view:—describe
the approach you are using to carry out and organize your study and the
assumptions you are making (make these very clear). You will most likely
develop/adopt at least two decision scenarios (alternatives) where each
alternative will have at least two criteria and incorporates risk analysis. You
may need to assume some information (data) for Part B.
Results—Include all EXCEL printouts in the appendix but do a good
summary analysis of your computer results in this section. Please use hide
rows, or hide column (to hide the middle part of a long and large sheet), or
“fit-in-one-page” feature to print one sheet in one page.),
Conclusion and recommendations—take your computer results one step
further by making relevant interpretation of those results
o
to answer the study questions that you pose in the introduction
section and
o
to try to fully accomplish your study objective.
1
EECS 352: Eng. Economics
Term Project Case Study Professor Malakooti
This should include a recommendation of what choice to take and the
reasoning/justification behind your recommendation.
Generate an Excel sheet for each analysis using the exact format of the
template shown in the Appendix (displayed at the end of this document).
The format of the report should be as following.
Introduction including the background, rational and statement of the problem
Model description: a complete detail of the mathematical model showing the
decision variables, the objective function, and constraints. For each key relation, a
short description should be given.
Result and Analysis: summary description of results and answer to questions
including all sensitivity analysis as appropriate.
Conclusions and recommendations
Appendix A: computer outputs.
Appendix B: computer codes (if any).
Appendix C: table of coefficients (if any).
Appendix D: Extra Credit (Provide Your Suggestions for Improving this Case Study; you
may also provide appropriate data for your suggested questions).
YouTube links
.
The following links should help you visualize how the Sheet Molding Compound (SMC)
Process works.
1-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDv0hD2ooGs
2-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e4Nm0jzpu7o
Preview YouTube video SMC Manhole Covers-Zhejiang Resin Municipal Facility Co.,
2
EECS 352: Eng. Economics
Term Project Case Study Professor Malakooti
Preview YouTube video Moulage Des SMC Haute pression
3
EECS 352: Eng. Economics
Term Project Case Study Professor Malakooti
Economic Analysis of a Modified Conveyor System
at Buick-Oldsmobile-Cadillac
Concepts illustrated:
Payback period, present worth analysis, rate of return analysis,
depreciation, and development of project cash flows.
Required Readings:
Text Book and Handouts of Professor Malakooti
______________________
1.
Background
The Buick-Oldsmobile-Cadillac (BOC) plant in Lansing, Michigan, is involved in the fabrication
and assembly of the Olds Calais, Buick Somerset Regal, and Pontiac Grand Am. A small part of
the total operation is the sheet molding compound (SMC) area where plastic parts are formed
from sheets of plastic material. Front-end panels (the front part of the car where the lights are
housed) are produced here, and a conveyor system is used to transport the panels after they are
formed. This case study examines an economic justification analysis for a proposed modification
of the conveyor system that would decrease the number of workers needed while improving
quality and facilitating material flow.
2.
Description of Present SMC Prime and Finish Process
The SMC prime and finish operation starts on the first floor with stud drivers as shown in Fig 3.1.
______________________________________________________________________
© 2001 by Chan S. Park, Department of Industrial & Systems Engineering, Auburn University - This case
is developed for classroom use only.
4
EECS 352: Eng. Economics
Term Project Case Study Professor Malakooti
Here a machine screws a two-ended bolt into each front end panel so that it can be attached to the
car later. The conveyor then moves the panels upstairs where they are washed and primed. Next,
the conveyor moves the panels through an oven to heat-treat the prime coating and then returns
them to the first floor. An inspector checks each panel for pits and defects and marks them for the
pit filler, who uses compound to fill in the defects. The compound must dry before it is sanded
(the next operation), but the current setup does not allow sufficient room for this to happen every
time. After the panel is sanded down, it travels up to the second floor again, where it is inspected
for any major repairs that must be made. If repairs are needed, the panel is taken of the conveyor;
otherwise, it moves on to the washer, where any dust and debris is removed. The conveyor then
moves the panel up to the third floor to the second prime spray booth and back down to the
second floor, where it is processed through an oven.
The panel is inspected again, and the pit fill and sand operations are performed as necessary.
Again, the area currently allocated to this operation does not always allow the compound enough
time to dry. The conveyor moves the panels to final inspection and to the packing area. Once the
panels are packed, they must be moved via elevator to the first floor, where the shipping docks
are located. There is only one elevator, and if it malfunctions, there is no way to transport the
parts to the first floor.
The existing system is producing good quality front-end panels, but the current arrangement
requires that the conveyor travel frequently between three floors and separates two similar
operations, requiring two supervisors.
The finished and packed parts must also be moved from the second floor packing area down to
the first floor with an elevator. In addition, the repair and maintenance for the conveyor system
will require an estimated $180,000 in the upcoming year alone in order to keep it in operable
condition. Projected maintenance costs for later years are unavailable but they are estimated to be
around $100,000 per year.
3
The Proposed System
The proposed system would be a modification of the current prime and finish conveyor system. It
would reduce the number of trips made between floors, use just one supervisor to oversee similar
operations, eliminate the need for the elevator, and reduce the number of employees needed for
the prime and finish operation.
The proposed system under would still be used to move the panels along a specified route while
different operations are performed on them. The major change is that almost all of the major
operations would be performed on the second floor as shown in Figure 3.2.
The areas needed for
the two pit fill and sanding operations would be located in the same general area, thus requiring
only one supervisor; the result should be better control of and more uniform standards for those
operations. There would be more room between the pit filling station and the sanding operation so
the compound would have an adequate amount of time to dry, resulting in better quality.
A sanding station for hood line sanding would be added after the stud driver machines in the
proposed process. (The hood line is where the front-end panel meets the hood of the car an area
very visible to the consumer.) In an effort to improve quality, it has been determined that this job
should receive careful attention and be performed before the initial priming process.
5
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help