c01Exploration_1_1_Interactive_Workbook-4
.pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of Nebraska, Lincoln *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
218
Subject
Statistics
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
Pages
8
Uploaded by ChiefPencil13196
Exploration 1.1 Can Dogs Understand Human Cues? 1
Note:
To ensure full functionality, including saving text in input fields and adding images in image fields, please download and use Adobe Acrobat Reader (free) or any Adobe Acrobat DC product.
Student Name:
Exploration 1.1 Can Dogs Understand Human Cues?
Dogs have been domesticated for about 14,000 years. In that time, have they been able to de-
velop an understanding of human gestures such as pointing or glancing? How about similar nonhuman cues? Researchers Udell, Giglio, and Wynne tested a small number of dogs in order to answer these questions. In this exploration, we will first see whether dogs can understand human gestures as well as nonhuman gestures. To test this, the researchers positioned the dogs about 2.5 meters from the experimenter. Two cups were placed, one on each side of the experimenter. The experimenter would perform some sort of gesture (pointing, bowing, looking) toward one of the cups or there would be some other nonhuman gesture (a mechanical arm pointing, a doll pointing, or a stuffed animal looking) toward one of the cups. The researchers would then see whether the dog would go to the cup that was indicated. There were six dogs tested. We will look at one of the dogs in two of his sets of trials. This dog, a four-year-old mixed breed, was named Harley. Each trial involved one gesture and one pair of cups, with a total of 10 trials in a set.
We will start out by looking at one set of trials where the experimenter bowed toward one of the cups to see whether Harley would go to that cup.
lightpoet/Shutterstock.com
STEP 1: State the research question.
1. Based on the description of the study, state the research question.
STEP 2: Design a study and collect data. Harley was tested 10 times and 9 of those times he chose the correct cup.
2. What are the observational units?
3. Identify the variable in the study. What are the possible outcomes of this variable? Is this variable quantitative or categorical?
Definition
The set of observational units on which we collect data is called the sample
. The number of observational units in the sample is the sample size
. A statistic
is a number summarizing the results in the sample.
STEP 3: Explore the data. With categorical data, we typically report the number of “suc-
cesses” or the proportion of successes as the statistic.
4. What is the number of observational units (sample size) in this study?
2
CHAPTER 1
Significance: How Strong Is the Evidence? 5. Determine the observed statistic and produce a simple bar graph of the data (have one bar for the proportion of times Harley picked the correct cup and another for the proportion of times he picked the wrong cup).
6. If the research conjecture is that Harley can understand what the experimenter means when they bow toward an object, is the statistic in the direction suggested by the research conjecture?
7. Could Harley have gotten 9 out of 10 correct even if he really didn’t understand the human gesture and so was randomly guessing between the two cups?
8. Do you think it is likely Harley would have gotten 9 out of 10 correct if he was just guessing randomly each time? STEP 4: Draw inferences beyond the data. There are two possibilities for why Harley chose the correct cup 9 out of 10 times:
• He is merely picking a cup at random and in these 10 trials happened to guess correctly in 9 of them. That is, he got more than half correct just by random chance alone.
• He is doing something other than merely guessing and perhaps understands what the experimenters mean when they bow towards the cup.
The unknown long-run proportion (i.e., probability) that Harley will choose the correct cup is called a parameter
. Definition
For a random process, a parameter
is a long-run numerical property of the process.
We don’t know the value of the parameter, but the two possibilities listed above suggest two different possibilities.
9. What is the value of the parameter if Harley is picking a cup at random? Give a specific value.
Exploration 1.1 Can Dogs Understand Human Cues? 3
10. What is the possible range of values (greater than or less than some value) for the parameter if Harley is not just guessing and instead understands the experimenter?
We will show you how statisticians use simulation to make a statement about the strength of evidence for these two possible statements about the parameter’s value. The Chance Model
Statisticians often use chance models
to generate data from random processes to help them investigate the process. In particular, they can see whether the ob-
served statistic is consistent with the values of the statistic simulated by the chance model. If we determine that Harley’s results are not consistent with the results from the chance model, we will consider this to be evidence against the chance model and in favor of the research con-
jecture, that he understands the bowing gesture. In this case, we would say Harley’s results are statistically significant
, meaning unlikely to have occurred by chance alone.
Definition
A result is statistically significant
if it is unlikely to occur just by random chance. If our observed result appears to be consistent with the chance model, we say that the chance model is plausible
or believable.
We can’t perform the actual study more times in order to assess the second possibility, but we can simulate the behavior of Harley’s choices if we were to assume the first possibility (that he is simply guessing every time).
11. Explain how you could use a coin toss to represent Harley’s choices if he is guessing between the two cups each time. How many times do you have to flip the coin to represent one set of Harley’s attempts? What does heads represent?
12. If Harley was guessing randomly each time, on average, how many out of the 10 times would you expect him to choose the correct cup?
13. Simulate one repetition of Harley guessing randomly by flipping a coin 10 times (why 10?) and letting heads represent selecting the correct cup (“success”) and tails represent selecting the incorrect cup (“failure”). Count the number of heads in your 10 flips. Combine your results with the rest of the class to create a dotplot of the distribution for the number of heads out of 10 flips of a coin.
a. Where does 9 heads fall in the distribution? Would you consider it an unusual outcome or a fairly typical outcome for the number of heads in 10 flips?
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
Reading is fundamental to a teenager's ability to perform well in school. Assume a researcher is
interested in the ability of the number of books read over the summer to predict ACT Reading
scores. Using a random sample of 10 random high school students the researchers recorded the
number of books read over the summer and the students' ACT Reading scores.
Books Read (X) ACT Score (Y) (X- Xmean)
(Y - Ymean)
(X-Xmean)(Y-Ymean) (X-Xmean)?
(Y - Ymean)?
2
16
-5.4
-14.9
81
29
221
2
19
-5.4
-11.9
64
29
141
3
17
-4.4
-13.9
61
20
192
4
25
-3.4
-5.9
20
12
34
21
-3.4
-9.9
34
12
97
24
-1.4
-6.9
10
2
47
6
21
-1.4
-9.9
14
2
97
8
24
0.6
-6.9
-4
47
7
27
-0.4
-3.9
2
15
10
22
2.6
-8.9
-23
7
78
Total
52
216
259.1
113.3
969.3
МEAN
7.4
30.9
a. Identify the regression line using the number of books read to predict ACT Reading
score. Use a = .05 to evaluate the quality of the prediction of the regression line.
b. What is the predicted ACT Reading score when 5 books are read?
arrow_forward
Why won't the whiteboard image show up?
arrow_forward
Give an example of a refinement in mathematical modeling with contextual explanation.
arrow_forward
Next summer you decide to enjoy the post-Covid world by attending some baseball games. You keep the stats of your
favorite players and decide to examine if there is any connection between Home Runs and Runs Batted In.
a) Fill in the empty cells in the table below. (If you are concerned a portion of the table is not showing up in your
word processer look at the pdf version of the exam).
Home Runs
Runs Batted In
Player
(X)
(Y)
x-X
y-ỹ
(x-X)(y-ỹ)
Buxton
4
14
Sano
5
26
Donaldson
13
Kirilloff
3
14
Polanco
4
24
Кepler
6.
11
Totals
24
b) Calculate the correlation coefficient (r).
Use Sx=1.414 and Sy = 6.325 while I know you can calculate standard deviations I have gone ahead
and done so for you.
SHOW YOUR WORK. (Write down the equation and plug in the correct values, the correct
answer alone will not get full points.)
r =
C.) Let's say you want to predict how many Runs Batted In a player would have based on their Home Runs. Write
down the general regression equation we could use to do so.
arrow_forward
The migration pattern of Monarch butterflies are tracked by a catch-and-release method in which individual
butterflies are tagged with a circular, lightweight sticker placed carefully on the wings so as not to impede
their ability to fly. The sticker contains a unique ID number. Volunteers across the U.S. and South America
capture the butterflies, record the IDs if they are tagged, and release them. This allows us to track the
locations each unique ID is found, allowing us to estimate the migration pattern. On average, 1 out of 100
captured butterflies are already tagged. Suppose you are a volunteer and capture 50 butterflies; let X denote
the number of those that are already tagged. What is the distribution of X? What is the probability that
you catch at least one tagged butterfly?
arrow_forward
A researcher is interested in studying how the number of books parents read to their children can influence a child's reading skills in kindergarten. She randomly assigns families with 5 year old children to either read their child 3 books per day, 2 book per day, or 1 book per day for the first 2 months of kindergarten. They then measure the children's reading ability.
How could the confound be fixed for this scenario? Be sure to tell me what technique you are using (constancy, repeated measures, randomization, elimination, or balancing), as well as how you would apply that technique to this specific scenario, and how that would fix this confound.
arrow_forward
I need help please!
Describe the culture in America during the 1950s through 1970s. How did this culture influence mathematics education? What were the major shifts and changes that occurred during this time? How is it different from today's mathematics education?
arrow_forward
Define mathematical models.
arrow_forward
help
arrow_forward
Please do not write the answer in step 1 or step 2 boxes. The website doesn't allow me to see the full explanatin. Could you write it on paper and then post it as a pic? Please.
arrow_forward
Answer number 2
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Algebra & Trigonometry with Analytic Geometry
Algebra
ISBN:9781133382119
Author:Swokowski
Publisher:Cengage
Big Ideas Math A Bridge To Success Algebra 1: Stu...
Algebra
ISBN:9781680331141
Author:HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURT
Publisher:Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Algebra: Structure And Method, Book 1
Algebra
ISBN:9780395977224
Author:Richard G. Brown, Mary P. Dolciani, Robert H. Sorgenfrey, William L. Cole
Publisher:McDougal Littell
Mathematics For Machine Technology
Advanced Math
ISBN:9781337798310
Author:Peterson, John.
Publisher:Cengage Learning,
Related Questions
- Reading is fundamental to a teenager's ability to perform well in school. Assume a researcher is interested in the ability of the number of books read over the summer to predict ACT Reading scores. Using a random sample of 10 random high school students the researchers recorded the number of books read over the summer and the students' ACT Reading scores. Books Read (X) ACT Score (Y) (X- Xmean) (Y - Ymean) (X-Xmean)(Y-Ymean) (X-Xmean)? (Y - Ymean)? 2 16 -5.4 -14.9 81 29 221 2 19 -5.4 -11.9 64 29 141 3 17 -4.4 -13.9 61 20 192 4 25 -3.4 -5.9 20 12 34 21 -3.4 -9.9 34 12 97 24 -1.4 -6.9 10 2 47 6 21 -1.4 -9.9 14 2 97 8 24 0.6 -6.9 -4 47 7 27 -0.4 -3.9 2 15 10 22 2.6 -8.9 -23 7 78 Total 52 216 259.1 113.3 969.3 МEAN 7.4 30.9 a. Identify the regression line using the number of books read to predict ACT Reading score. Use a = .05 to evaluate the quality of the prediction of the regression line. b. What is the predicted ACT Reading score when 5 books are read?arrow_forwardWhy won't the whiteboard image show up?arrow_forwardGive an example of a refinement in mathematical modeling with contextual explanation.arrow_forward
- Next summer you decide to enjoy the post-Covid world by attending some baseball games. You keep the stats of your favorite players and decide to examine if there is any connection between Home Runs and Runs Batted In. a) Fill in the empty cells in the table below. (If you are concerned a portion of the table is not showing up in your word processer look at the pdf version of the exam). Home Runs Runs Batted In Player (X) (Y) x-X y-ỹ (x-X)(y-ỹ) Buxton 4 14 Sano 5 26 Donaldson 13 Kirilloff 3 14 Polanco 4 24 Кepler 6. 11 Totals 24 b) Calculate the correlation coefficient (r). Use Sx=1.414 and Sy = 6.325 while I know you can calculate standard deviations I have gone ahead and done so for you. SHOW YOUR WORK. (Write down the equation and plug in the correct values, the correct answer alone will not get full points.) r = C.) Let's say you want to predict how many Runs Batted In a player would have based on their Home Runs. Write down the general regression equation we could use to do so.arrow_forwardThe migration pattern of Monarch butterflies are tracked by a catch-and-release method in which individual butterflies are tagged with a circular, lightweight sticker placed carefully on the wings so as not to impede their ability to fly. The sticker contains a unique ID number. Volunteers across the U.S. and South America capture the butterflies, record the IDs if they are tagged, and release them. This allows us to track the locations each unique ID is found, allowing us to estimate the migration pattern. On average, 1 out of 100 captured butterflies are already tagged. Suppose you are a volunteer and capture 50 butterflies; let X denote the number of those that are already tagged. What is the distribution of X? What is the probability that you catch at least one tagged butterfly?arrow_forwardA researcher is interested in studying how the number of books parents read to their children can influence a child's reading skills in kindergarten. She randomly assigns families with 5 year old children to either read their child 3 books per day, 2 book per day, or 1 book per day for the first 2 months of kindergarten. They then measure the children's reading ability. How could the confound be fixed for this scenario? Be sure to tell me what technique you are using (constancy, repeated measures, randomization, elimination, or balancing), as well as how you would apply that technique to this specific scenario, and how that would fix this confound.arrow_forward
- I need help please! Describe the culture in America during the 1950s through 1970s. How did this culture influence mathematics education? What were the major shifts and changes that occurred during this time? How is it different from today's mathematics education?arrow_forwardDefine mathematical models.arrow_forwardhelparrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Algebra & Trigonometry with Analytic GeometryAlgebraISBN:9781133382119Author:SwokowskiPublisher:CengageBig Ideas Math A Bridge To Success Algebra 1: Stu...AlgebraISBN:9781680331141Author:HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURTPublisher:Houghton Mifflin HarcourtAlgebra: Structure And Method, Book 1AlgebraISBN:9780395977224Author:Richard G. Brown, Mary P. Dolciani, Robert H. Sorgenfrey, William L. ColePublisher:McDougal Littell
- Mathematics For Machine TechnologyAdvanced MathISBN:9781337798310Author:Peterson, John.Publisher:Cengage Learning,
Algebra & Trigonometry with Analytic Geometry
Algebra
ISBN:9781133382119
Author:Swokowski
Publisher:Cengage
Big Ideas Math A Bridge To Success Algebra 1: Stu...
Algebra
ISBN:9781680331141
Author:HOUGHTON MIFFLIN HARCOURT
Publisher:Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
Algebra: Structure And Method, Book 1
Algebra
ISBN:9780395977224
Author:Richard G. Brown, Mary P. Dolciani, Robert H. Sorgenfrey, William L. Cole
Publisher:McDougal Littell
Mathematics For Machine Technology
Advanced Math
ISBN:9781337798310
Author:Peterson, John.
Publisher:Cengage Learning,