preview

Evolutionary Theory Of Antibiotic Resistance

Better Essays

Antibiotic resistance has become a hot topic amongst scientists and healthcare professionals. It would be rare to observe in a clinical setting and not see some type of antibiotic resistant infection being treated. Scientists and medical doctors are scrambling trying to develop plans to discover new drugs or at least dampen the rate at which these organisms are developing resistance. Evolutionary biologists are claiming this type of resistance as proof of evolution, but is that a statement that is really supported by the evidence? It depends on which type of evolution is being talked about first. Macroevolution is the theory that one species can evolve into a totally different species. Microevolution is the change of genotypes and phenotypes …show more content…

A methicillin-resistant staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is still staphylococcus aureus. New genetic material is not being made, just alterations to the already present information. What this shows is microevolution because the genotype has been altered in order for the bacterium to survive conditions where methicillin or methicillin derivatives are present. The question still remains, is the development of antibiotic resistance in organisms a good example for evolutionary theory? Antibiotic resistance is not good proof for evolution because it does not lead to a higher fitness in the organism but to an organism that is dysfunctional that cannot survive outside of the specific conditions that allowed it to survive. Also, the mutations needed to acquire resistance are highly specific which makes evolutionary theory an unlikely source. However, it does provide an interesting point for creation of an intelligent designer if it is thought of in addition to the organosubstrate …show more content…

This theory developed by Joseph Francis states that microbes and viruses were created as a link to macro-organisms to provide a substrate upon which all macro-organisms can survive and thrive in ecosystems (Francis). The evidence of this can be seen in symbiotic relationships between microbes and macro-organisms that provide the macro-organisms the ability to live and thrive. An example of this would be the intestinal microbes in humans that provide digestive enzymes, vitamins, and other nutrients that are vital to the health of the human (Francis). Another example would be nitrogen fixing bacteria that promote plant growth. This would include Burkholderia phymatum and Cupriavidus taiwanensis with Mimosa plants. (Geoffrey et al., 2006). Also, Francis mentions the Rhizobium bacterium which also fixes nitrogen for plant use (Francis). Without these microbes, the macro-organisms would not be able to function to their best capability and could possibly cause the breakdown of all life

Get Access