preview

Normative Context Of Advice

Decent Essays

In Goldsmith and Fitch’s 1997 article “The Normative Context of Advice as Social Support” the dilemmas associated with giving, seeking, and taking advice are examined. The overarching goal of this study is to analyze what the normative actions of support, specifically advice, are. The research questions that were taken into consideration are as follows: “what goals are pursued as people ask for, and give, advice;” “what identity and relational implications of advice shape givers’ and receivers’ reactions to advice;” and “what situational, conversational, and cultural constraints are relevant to participants’ evaluation of advice?” (Goldsmith & Fitch, 1997) Multiple dilemmas were found pertaining to advice including honesty versus support, caring vesrsus intrusive, and respect versus autonomy. Each of these qualities are present in every interaction in which advice is given, asked for, or received. As for the first pair of qualities, honesty and support, it manifests itself in the situation. How the advice is taken is dependent on the present circumstances, rather than on relational context. For example, if someone were to ask to be “brutally honest,” this does not constitute perpetual honesty; instead, it allows a temporary period during which being …show more content…

Furthermore, it would be great to break down the population into subgroups of males and females. I think this could yield some interesting results because of the communication differences between genders. Deborah Tannen makes some interesting points about this in her book You Just Don’t Understand. I believe that it is possible that women are more likely to take advice as caring than men because they tend to focus on the cooperative aspect of a relationship, whereas men tend to focus on the competitive aspect (Tannen, 1990). Then, the gender of the person receiving the advice would impact the response to

Get Access