Researchers studied 393 patients in a hospital’s coronary care unit. In the experiment, volunteers were asked to pray daily for a patient’s rapid recovery and for the prevention of complications and death.
None of the patients knew if he or she was being prayed for. None of the volunteers or patients knew each other. The research team categorized how each patient fared as “good,” “intermediate,” or “bad.” They concluded that “prayed for” patients fared a little better than other patients—the experiment having documented results that seemed to support the prediction that prayer might have beneficial effects for seriously ill patients.
The results brought a storm of criticism, mostly from scientists who cited bias in the experimental design. For instance, the patients were categorized after the experiment was over, instead of as they were undergoing treatment, so the team already knew which ones had improved, stayed about the same, or gotten worse. Why do you suppose the experiment generated a heated response from many in the scientific community? Can you think of at least one other variable that might have affected the outcome of each patient’s illness?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 1 Solutions
EBK HUMAN BIOLOGY
- Create 2 family nursing care planarrow_forwardCreate 2 nursing care planarrow_forwardRead Nurse Staffing and Inpatient Hospital Mortality. Write a Memorandum (no more than 2 pages) directed to your faculty answering the questions: What questions the did researchers try to answer? What study design was chosen for this study? Why? What data was collected? Why? What biases the study was subjected to? What conclusions were made? How a healthcare manager can use this study to guide departmental staffing?arrow_forward
- What does Freedman say about Equipoise and the ethics of clinical research, does he respect the principle of Beneficence?arrow_forwardGive typing answer with explanation and conclusion The PPACA has a number of provisions that aim to increase access to care. Which of the following is NOT one of them? Please choose all that apply. Group of answer choices A)HRRP B)Ban discrimination based on preexisting conditions C)Individual mandate D)Medicaid Expansion E)Employer mandatearrow_forwardYou read a study in which 55 male participants (aged 55-70 years) were assessed for handgrip strength, and changes in cardiovascular health over a 2-year period. In the statistical analysis section of the paper you note that the researchers used regression analysis as the statistical procedure. The researchers identify the independent variable as handgrip strength, and the dependent variable as change in cardiovascular health. What do you think the research question could be?You read a study in which 55 male participants (aged 55-70 years) were assessed for handgrip strength, and changes in cardiovascular health over a 2-year period. In the statistical analysis section of the paper you note that the researchers used regression analysis as the statistical procedure. The researchers identify the independent variable as handgrip strength, and the dependent variable as change in cardiovascular health. What do you think the research question could be? Select one: a. Does handgrip strength…arrow_forward
- How could the Konstanz Information Miner KNIME Analytics platform be used to analyze health care data? What benefits does this software have in comparison to commercial products that have similar functionality and use?arrow_forwardFrom the "Spurious Correlation: Definition, Examples & Detecting" article by Jim Frost, why spurious correlation is an issue when it comes to analyzing and interpreting public health data? How does it impacts public health? What is an example of spurious correlation? What is the variables being correlated, what the relationships being suggested is, why you think it is a spurious correlation, and what (if any) mitigating or confounding variables may be?arrow_forwardIf a researcher with an interest in medicine wanted to gain more insight into the healthcare industry and profession and conduct qualitative interviews with professionals like a doctor or nurse, as well as potentially interviewing medical students: a) Describe the content the researcher may cover in the interviews. b) What may be the researcher’s hypothesis, presumptions, or expectations? c) How does conducting these interviews enhance the researcher’s understanding of the healthcare industry?arrow_forward
- A researcher is conducting an experiment testing whether a new pharmaceutical drug is able to effectively treat heartburn and has a physician assisting with the study involving volunteers who experience chronic heartburn. Which of the following descriptions most closely describes the control used in this study? Show answer choices The researcher has organized the patients into 4 groups, where patients either take 1 dose of the drug, 2 doses of the drug, 1 dose of the placebo, or 2 doses of the placebo. The physician asks patients to rate their heartburn discomfort on a scale from 1-10 every 5 minutes up to an hour. The physician and patients both do not know if they are receiving the actual drug or a placebo. The placebo pill contains just compressed sugar and no active drug. Patients are randomly selected and placed into the four categories.arrow_forwardMatch the outcomes to whether they are obtained from manipulative experiments or observational studies: 1 2 2 Inference of causality Tests for patterns and possible processes under natural conditions Tests of causes that are difficult to control 1. Manipulative experiments 2. Observational studiesarrow_forwardYour Medical Science degree goes well and eventually you become a General Practitioner. Based on all the information currently available, you estimate that the patient in your office has a one in four chance of having a particular serious disease. You order a diagnostic test with sensitivity of 95% and specificity of 90%. The result comes back positive. Based on all the information now available, the chance your patient really has the disease is closest to: Question 5 Select one: a. 55% b. 65% c. 85% d. 75%arrow_forward
- Human Biology (MindTap Course List)BiologyISBN:9781305112100Author:Cecie Starr, Beverly McMillanPublisher:Cengage LearningBiology Today and Tomorrow without Physiology (Mi...BiologyISBN:9781305117396Author:Cecie Starr, Christine Evers, Lisa StarrPublisher:Cengage Learning