Concept explainers
Videos
Rob Honeycutt created Timbuk2 to offer consumers the ability to make their own custom, three-panel messenger bags. And instead of following the standard strategy of manufacturing in Asia, Rob set up Timbuk2 in San Francisco with its own facility. But is this the best strategy? Should Timbuk2 consider moving production to China?
The image above displays a screenshot from Timbuk2’s online retailing website that allows customers to customize their messenger bag to their own particular tastes. A customer can select one color for each of the three panels and a separate color, if they want, for the Timbuk2 “swirl” logo. The color options change over time, to keep things “fresh,” but at any one time Timbuk2 generally offers at least 16 options for each panel and the logo.
Once customized, Timbuk2 manufactures the bag in San Francisco and then ships the bag to the customer within two to three days.
Timbuk2 sells bags through its online store for about $100 per bag. Although it would love to sell bags only through its website and to sell many more of them, the market for custom bags at this price point is only so big. So Timbuk2 sells bags through other channels as well. For example, retailers such as REI purchase a limited selection of bags to sell in their stores. While Timbuk2 appreciates sales through this wholesale channel, they don’t generate the same revenue per bag as the online channel—more like $35 per bag. Even though the wholesale bags generally do not involve nearly the same level of customization as the online bags (i.e., retailers tend to select more conservative color combinations), those bags are made on the same production line as the online bags. However, the promised lead time to wholesale customers is longer, more like two to three weeks.
Courtesy of TIMBUK2
The decision as to whether to send production to China involves a number of issues. Table 11.11 provides a cost comparison between production in San Francisco and in China. There is clearly a dramatic difference in labor costs on a per-hour basis, but the workers in San Francisco are slightly more productive (they require 49 minutes per bag instead of 63 minutes). Material costs do not differ between the two options, because in both cases materials are procured in China. It costs $1 per bag to send it from China via ocean carrier, but the lead time is probably eight weeks when all of the steps are accounted for (e.g., production, movement to the port, and actual shipping). To get a faster lead time would require air shipments, but that is much more expensive: $15 per bag.
TABLE 11.11 Production and Shipment Costs per Bag by Production Location
Of course, Table 11.11 doesn’t tell the entire story. There would be costs associated with finding a good supplier and monitoring that supplier. And it isn’t clear how Timbuk2’s customers would react to the move—from its start, Timbuk2 emphasized with pride that it was made in San Francisco. Does moving production to China eliminate part of the brand’s cache with customers?
Should it move production of custom bags to China? Should it move production of wholesale bags to China?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution
Chapter 11 Solutions
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT (LL)-W/ACCESS
Additional Business Textbook Solutions
Principles Of Operations Management
Operations Management
Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management (12th Edition)
Loose-leaf for Operations Management (The Mcgraw-hill Series in Operations and Decision Sciences)
OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN: DECISIONS & CASES (Mcgraw-hill Series Operations and Decision Sciences)
Business in Action (8th Edition)
- ESTRELLA is a bike retailer located in the outskirts of Bacolod City. ESTRELLA purchases bikes from STORAGEHUB in orders of 250 bikes which is the current economic order quantity. STORAGEHUB is now offering the following bulk discounts to its customers: Price 0% discount on orders less than 499 P3,500 10% discount on orders above 500 units - 999 3,150 15% discount on orders above 1,000 units 2,975 ESTRELLA is wondering if the EOQ model is still the most economical and whether increasing the order size would actually be more beneficial. Following information is relevant to forming the decision: Annual demand is 5000 units Ordering cost is $100 per order Annual holding cost is 25% How much is the EOQ for each quantity discount? How much should be the EOQ?arrow_forwardThe Bucks Grande exhibition baseball team plays 50 weeks each year and uses an average of 350 baseballs per week. The team orders baseballs from Coopers-Town, Inc., a ball manufacturer noted for six-sigma-level consistency and high product quality. The cost to order baseballs is $100 per order and the annual holding cost per ball is 38 percent of the purchase price. Coopers-Town’s price structure is: Order Quantity Price per Unit 1–999 $7.50 1,000–4999 $7.25 5,000 or more $6.50 a. How many baseballs should the team buy per order? b. What is the total annual cost associated with the best order quantity? c. Coopers-Town, Inc., discovers that, owing to special manufacturing processes required for the Buck’s baseballs, it has underestimated the setup time required on a capacity-constrained piece of machinery. Coopers-Town adds another category to the price structure to provide an incentive for larger orders and thereby hopes to…arrow_forwardEcho Airplane buys and sells its products. One of them has the following demand forecasts for the next 5 months. data: month 1= 55 month 2= 85 month 3= 105 month 4= 120 month 5= 115 It costs $20 to place an order, the product cost is $2.00, and the monthly cost of holding inventory is 12.5%. Use the minimum unit cost (LUC) heuristic to determine the ordering sequence for following monthly demands a) Calculate the cost of the heuristic Please do fast ASAParrow_forward
- Red Corporation uses the reorder point modelto plan its purchases. It sellsitssole productat the following daily amounts:Minimum=30,000; Average=40,000;Maximum=60,000. Its supplier takes 3 dayson average and 4 days maximum to deliverthe order. The-reorder point would be A. 240,000B. 160,000C. 120,000D. 90,000arrow_forwardPlease help solve this within 45 min.. please Mega Sdn . Bhd is a wholesaler which buys and sells wide range of products. One of the products is called M3. Each month the company buys 100 units of M3 at cost of RM20 each. Each unit of M3 requires two square feet of space at a cost of RM4 per square foot per annum. Other holding costs are estimated to be 10% of the purchase price. For each order placed, it costs the company RM700. Required: Determine the economic order quantity by using formula.arrow_forwardPlease do not give solution in image format thanku A mail-order house uses 16,820 boxes a year. Carrying costs are 60 cents per box a year, and ordering costs are $96. The following price schedule applies. Number of Boxes Price per Box 1,000 to 1,999 $1.25 2,000 to 4,999 1.20 5,000 to 9,999 1.15 10,000 or more 1.10 a. Determine the optimal order quantity. (Round your answer to the nearest whole number.) Optimal order quantity boxes b. Determine the number of orders per year.arrow_forward
- Fisk Corporation is trying to improve its inventory control system and has installed an online computer at its retail stores. Fisk anticipates sales of 112, 500 units per year, an ordering cost of $3 per order, and carrying costs of $1.20 per unit. a. What is the economic ordering quantity? b. How many orders will be placed during the year? c. What will the average inventory be? d. What is the total cost of ordering and carrying inventory?arrow_forwardBIKO is a bike retailer located in the outskirts of Paris. BIKO purchases bikes from PMX in orders of 250 bikes which is the current economic order quantity. PMX is now offering the following bulk discounts to its customers: 2% discount on orders above 200 units 4% discount on orders above 500 units 6% discount on orders above 600 units BIKO is wondering if the EOQ model is still the most economical and whether increasing the order size would actually be more beneficial. Following information is relevant to forming the decision: Annual demand is 5000 units Ordering cost is $100 per order Annual holding cost is comprised of the following: 5% insurance premium for the average inventory held during the year calculated using the net purchase price Warehousing cost of $6 per unit Purchase price is $200 per unit before discount (Hint: We need to compare the total inventory cost of the order quantities at the various discount levels with that of the economic order quantity)arrow_forwardExplain how RPM can be used to increase retailer demand for inventories and thereby increase manufacturer profit. Explain whether profitable RPM can either increase or decrease welfare and how this depends on the variation in demand. Use diagrams and verbal explanation to explain your answer. Demonstrate the profit and welfare consequences of RPM by solving the 'RPM and Inventories Model' model done in class for the parameter value indicated below. RPM and Inventories Model Manufacturer MC = 0, Dealer MC = 0, Low and high demand are equally likely Low demand: qL = 1 - pL, High demand: qH = S(1 - pH) Parameter value: S = 4arrow_forward
- Tasty Treats is a distributor of candy and snack products serving customers in a six-state region of the midwestern United States. Bill Jones, chief operations officer, has been concerned about inventory levels and inventory performance at Tasty Treats for quite some time. In speaking with Jim Busfield, chief executive officer of Tasty Treats, Bill voiced some of his concerns: “Jim, we carry over 5,000 different items in inventory. I have a feeling that we just don’t have a good handle on the proper approach to managing this part of our operations. We don’t have any real analysis that tells us how much we should carry of each item. We just use simple rules of thumb to determine how much we should order from our suppliers. For example, we sell an average of 100 cases of Chocolate Chewies every day. When we order Chocolate Chewies from our supplier, it usually takes about 10 days for us to get the order. So, we order 1,000 cases of Chocolate Chewies every 10 days. I also try to keep an…arrow_forwardRed Corporation uses the reorder point model to plan its purchases. It sells its sole product at the following daily amounts: Minimum=30,000; Average=40,000; Maximum=60,000. Its supplier takes 3 days on average and 4 days maximum to deliver the order. The-reorder point would be: A. 240,000B. 160,000C. 120,000D. 90,000arrow_forwardWilliam Beville's Computer Training School in Richmond stocks notebooks for sale and would like to reduce its inventory cost by determining the optimal number of notebooks to order in each order. The ordering cost for each order is $27. The annual demand is 19455 units. The annual cost of holding each unit is $6. Each notebook costs $12. The school has a year of 250 working days. When a new order of notebooks is made, the supplier takes 4 days to deliver it. Show your work. 1. What inventory management model should we use to solve this problem? Model Economic Quantity to Order Model for discount purchases Model Economic Quantity to Produce Model to handle dependent demand 2. What is the optimal number of notebooks to make in each order? Response 3. What is the annual ordering cost (AOC)? Response 4. What is the Annual Holding Cost (AHC)? Response 5. What is the annual product cost (APC)? Response 6. What is the annual total cost of managing inventory (ATC) Answer 7. What would be the…arrow_forward
Purchasing and Supply Chain ManagementOperations ManagementISBN:9781285869681Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. PattersonPublisher:Cengage Learning