Case summary: The company W employed a woman A for making detailed notes of the discussion for the script writing. During the meetings, three of the scriptwriters made obscene and vulgar jokes and showcased sexual gestures, but W never complained about it. They also conversated about their personal sexual fantasies and experience to further use it in story. Sometime later, A lost her job and filed a lawsuit against the company W alleging that her termination was a result of racial discrimination.
To find: The type of A’s claim of discrimination.
Explanation of Solution
Title VII of Civil Rights Act forbids any kind of discrimination, intentional and unintentional, at the workplace. In a case of intentional discrimination, the person must show a prima facie case of discrimination by the employer to the Court while unintentional discrimination can be inferred from the practices and procedures of the employer.
In the given case as A does not have enough evidence to prove intentional discrimination as she was not discriminated at any stage, she can bring her claim under unintentional discrimination.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 21 Solutions
Bundle: The Legal Environment Of Business: Text And Cases, 10th + Mindtap Business Law, 1 Term (6 Months) Printed Access Card
- Patrick Clawson was described by reporter Karen Branch-Brioso in a newspaper story as a “1970s era St. Louis journalist turned private eye turned FBI informant.” The story was published in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. The fact that he had been characterized as an informant bothered Clawson, who saw it as damaging to his reputation. Accordingly, he brought a libel case against the Post-Dispatch. Recall that to be libelous, a statement must be false and “hold the victim up to ridicule, contempt, or hatred.” Clawson would have preferred the term whistleblower rather than informant because that term commands more respect. Why is the use of the term informant to describe Clawson not libelous?arrow_forwardABC Company is a large organization that employs over 500 people. One of its employees, John, has been having a conflict with his supervisor, Sarah, for several months. John feels that Sarah is unfair and unreasonable in her expectations of him, while Sarah believes that John is not meeting the required standards for his role. 1. What are some potential methods of dispute resolution that ABC Company could use to resolve the conflict between John and Sarah? 2. Assume that ABC Company decides to use mediation to resolve the dispute. What steps should the mediator take to help John and Sarah reach a mutually agreeable solution?arrow_forwardOn or about 10th September 2018, as a member of the academic staff of a Caribbean University byyour collective verbal statements, you caused personal discomfort of a sexual nature to a student,after offering her a lift/ride to a restaurant down town to buy something to eat, then asking: “doyou have your visa” and “do you have a boyfriend” and by stating that she is a “very beautiful girl”and you did not want anyone to “spoil her” and that you wanted to take her for lunch sometime andthat she was “very beautiful”. On or about 10 September 2018, whilst offering the young lady the lift /ride as described above,you misconducted yourself as a member of the academic staff of the University by touching herwithout her consent in a sexual manner by caressing her right knee with your left hand, causing herto push away your hand. A few weeks later, the lecturer sent pictures of himself to the named student without her consentand sent videos and pictures of himself from his personal cell phone…arrow_forward
- Carole Smith, an Apostolic Christian, worked as sales associate at Nickels Department Store. One afternoon, during a break, Smith participated in a conversation about God, homosexuality, and same-sex marriages. The next day, an employee told the manager that Smith made inappropriate comments about gays to Casey, a Nickels employee who was gay. Over the next five weeks, Nickels investigated the incident by interviewing and obtaining statements from employees who were present during the conversation. In his statement, Casey reported that Smith pointed her finger and said that God does not accept gays, that gays should not be allowed to marry or have children, and that they will burn in hell. Three employees confirmed Smith’s statements. Nickels terminated Smith's employment after concluding she had engaged in serious harassment in violation of its Discrimination and Harassment Prevention Policy. This policy, of which Smith was aware, prohibits employees from engaging in conduct that…arrow_forwardOn or about 10th September 2018, as a member of the academic staff of a Caribbean University by your collective verbal statements, you caused personal discomfort of a sexual nature to a student, after offering her a lift/ride to a restaurant downtown to buy something to eat, then asking: “do you have your visa” and “do you have a boyfriend” and by stating that she is a “very beautiful girl” and you did not want anyone to “spoil her” and that you wanted to take her for lunch sometime and that she was “very beautiful”. On or about 10 September 2018, whilst offering the young lady the lift /ride as described above, you misconducted yourself as a member of the academic staff of the University by touching her without her consent in a sexual manner by caressing her right knee with your left hand, causing her to push away your hand. A few weeks later, the lecturer sent pictures of himself to the named student without her consent and sent videos and pictures of himself from his personal cell…arrow_forwardMohamed Arafi, a naturalized U.S. citizen from Morocco, works as a valet dry cleaner for the Mandarin Oriental Hotel in Washington, D.C. In December 2010, a supervisor allegedly prohibited Arab or Muslim workers from going on floors occupied by a delegation of Israeli diplomats. The supervisor allegedly told Arafi, “You know how the Israelis are with Arabs and Muslims.” Arafi says he complied with his supervisor’s instructions but consequently lost out on tips. He subsequently complained to another supervisor and the hotel’s director of human resources. Arafi says his work hours were cut, and that his colleagues said demeaning things about Muslims to him after the incident became known to them. Arafi brought suit under Title VII, alleging disparate treatment resulting in an adverse employment action (the loss of tips), as well as retaliation. The Mandarin Hotel claimed a national security exemption. Would either of Arafi’s claims be successful? Would the Hotel’s? [Arafi v. Mandarin…arrow_forward
- Johnson, president of the First National Bank of A, believes that it is appropriate to employ only female tellers. Hence, First National refuses to employ Ken Baker as a teller but does offer him a maintenance position at the same salary. Baker brings a cause of action against First National Bank. Is First National illegally discriminating based on gender? Why?arrow_forwardDemarco just graduated from Texas University and had been snatched up by Xeon Natural Resources Incorporated, one of the top natural resource extraction companies in the world. Because he was Brazilian, bilingual, and spoke several specific Brazilian dialects, his stationing in Brazil was a no-brainer. Xeon was deeply involved with a project within the Brazilian rain forests in mining an extremely valuable element called niobium. Niobium is a rare earth element essential for micro-alloying steel as well as other products such as jet engines, rocket subassemblies, superconducting magnets, and super alloys. Brazil accounts for 92 percent of all niobium mined, and Xeon Natural mines much of the element in Brazil. Xeon discovered a large niobium deposit and estimates the corporation could make an additional $5 billion in profits over the next two decades. Demarco soon discovered he was one of several employees assigned to explain to the indigenous population that Xeon wanted to extract the…arrow_forward
- BUSN 11 Introduction to Business Student EditionBusinessISBN:9781337407137Author:KellyPublisher:Cengage LearningEssentials of Business Communication (MindTap Cou...BusinessISBN:9781337386494Author:Mary Ellen Guffey, Dana LoewyPublisher:Cengage LearningAccounting Information Systems (14th Edition)BusinessISBN:9780134474021Author:Marshall B. Romney, Paul J. SteinbartPublisher:PEARSON
- International Business: Competing in the Global M...BusinessISBN:9781259929441Author:Charles W. L. Hill Dr, G. Tomas M. HultPublisher:McGraw-Hill Education