Given situation: Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law. Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding. To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Question

Want to see the full answer?

Answer 1

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Students have asked these similar questions

Trevor Rowe a well known businessman saw an article in the gleaner that indicated that he was a jail bird. As a result, he lost customers. He wrote to the gleaner, seeking a retraction of the story, and found out that there was in fact another man in the community with the same name who had gone to jail. What is the position of either party? The Gleaner can prevent litigation by offering to make amends. The Gleaner doesn’t have to retract the story as it was true for one of the men. There is no action as the story was already published. The businessman can go straight to Court. There is no action at there are two persons with the same name.

Olga, a resident of Maine, was recently injured by a defective product produced by Home Appliance Corporation, which is incorporated in Delaware but has its company headquarters in Virgina. Olga purchased the defective product in Maine. Olga is suing Home Appliance for $60,000. Which courts would have personal jurisdiction in this case? Would a federal court have jurisdiction? Why or why not?

Sam Simpleton, a resident of Kansas, and Nellie Naive, a resident of Missouri, each bought $85,000 in stock at local offices in their home States from Evil Stockbrokers, Inc. (“Evil”), a business incorporated in Delaware, with its principal place of business in Kansas. Both Simpleton and Naive believe that they were cheated by Evil Stockbrokers and would like to sue Evil for fraud. Assuming that no Federal question is at issue, assess the accuracy of the following statements: a. Simpleton can sue Evil in a Kansas State trial court. b. Simpleton can sue Evil in a Federal district court in Kansas. c. Naive can sue Evil in a Missouri State trial court. d. Naive can sue Evil in a Federal district court in Missouri.

Answer 2

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 3

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 4

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 5

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 6

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Answer 7

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Answer 8

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

Answer 9

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

Answer 10

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

Answer 11

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

Answer 12

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 13

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 14

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 15

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 16

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 17

Ch. 3 - Prob. 1CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 2CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 3CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 4CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 5CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 1Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 2Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 3Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 4Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 5Q

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Want to see the full answer?

Chapter 3 Solutions