Concept explainers
CASE STUDY| Fish tales
Aquatic vegetation overgrowth, usually controlled by dredging or herbicides, represents a significant issue in maintaining private and public waterways. In 1963, diploid grass carp were introduced in Arkansas to consume vegetation, but they reproduced prodigiously and spread to eventually become a hazard to aquatic ecosystems in 35 states. In the 1980s, many states adopted triploid grass carp as an alternative because of their high, but not absolute, sterility and their longevity of seven to ten years. Today, most states require permits for vegetation control by triploid carp, requiring their containment in the body of water to which they are introduced. Genetic modifications of organisms to achieve specific outcomes willcertainly become more common in the future and raise several interesting questions.
Taking triploid carp as an example, what controversies may emerge as similar modified species become available for widespread use?
To review:
The controversies that emerge from using modified species available for widespread use, keeping in mind the case of triploid grass carp.
Introduction:
There exist aquatic weeds which is harmful to the survival of other species. Grass carp are genetically modified so that it could wipe away the population of these weeds. These genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are made to be survived for a longer time, for about a period of five to ten years.
Explanation of Solution
Grass carp is a genetically modified fish which is used for controlling aquatic weed but there are also few controversies associated with their use-
1) Incorrect insertion of the gene of interest- During the insertion of the gene of interest, there might occur some undesirable changes in the functionality of organism as while creating triploid grass carp, they may harm aquatic vegetation without disrupting the weed population.
2) Harmful to the environment- Due to gene insertion, the modified organism may start producing toxic substances and releasing it in the environment, affecting the environment negatively. For example- some portion of weed eaten by modified grass carp may not be completely digested and excreted to further cause algal blooms.
3) Resistance by pests and weeds towards the GMOs:A prolonged use of genetically modified organisms against insects, pests or weeds, may cause the development of resistance in these organisms against the GMOs. Hence, the GMOs should be used carefully against other organisms.
4) Disruption to biodiversity and vegetation: If a wide population of a particular species is wiped out then this would disrupt the biodiversity and vegetation of that place. For example- if triploid grass carp starts eating the useful aquatic vegetation along with the weeds then this will pose a harmful impact on the aquatic environment.
5) Harmful to human health- In some cases, GMOs have shown to leave behind toxic substances which cannot be degraded when such substances contaminate a region then it may be later consumed by humans which would result in serious health problems.
Thus, it can be concluded that GMOs are effective and necessary to be used in the modern world but it also has certain drawbacks.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 6 Solutions
ESSENTIALS OF GENETICS ALC & MOD MSTG/ET VP
- 1. Assume that figure (A) represents a normal karyotype of this animal. What is the diploid number of thisanimal? 2.Cell (A) contains 3.1 billion (3.1 x 109) base pairs of DNA. Each nucleosome has about 200 bp of DNAwrapped around the histone core.a. What is the maximum number of nucleosomes that can be present in the cell?b. What is the maximum number of H2A histone protein molecules that can be present in the cell?arrow_forwardGENETICS Question; 1. Give the genotypes and its ratio of the dihybrid cross of FIGURE 7. Regarding this problem, you may refer the genotype of the monohybrid cross of pea flower color in Figure 6.arrow_forwardProblem Solving: In Drosophila, the gene that controls red eye color (dominant) versus white eye color is on the X chromosomes. What are the expected phenotypic results if a heterozygous female is crossed with a white-eyed male? In cats, S = short hair; s = long hair; XC = black coat; Xc = yellow coat; XCXc = tortoiseshell (calico) coat. If a long-haired yellow male is crossed with a tortoiseshell female homozygous for short hair, what are the expected phenotypic results?arrow_forward
- Controlling the overgrowth of invasive aquatic vegetation is asignificant problem in the waterways of most U.S. states.Originally, herbicides and dredging were used for control, butin 1963, diploid Asian carp were introduced in Alabama and Arkansas.Unfortunately, through escapes and illegal introductions, the carpspread rapidly and became serious threats to aquatic ecosystems in45 states. Beginning in 1983, many states began using triploid, sterilegrass carp as an alternative, because of their inability to reproduce,their longevity, and their voracious appetite. On the other hand, thisgenetically modified exotic species, if not used properly, can reduceor eliminate desirable plants and outcompete native fish, causing moredamage than good. The use of one exotic species to control otherexotic species has had a problematic history across the globe, generatingcontroversy and criticism. Newer methods for genetic modificationof organisms to achieve specific outcomes will certainly becomemore…arrow_forwardControlling the overgrowth of invasive aquatic vegetation is asignificant problem in the waterways of most U.S. states.Originally, herbicides and dredging were used for control, butin 1963, diploid Asian carp were introduced in Alabama and Arkansas.Unfortunately, through escapes and illegal introductions, the carpspread rapidly and became serious threats to aquatic ecosystems in45 states. Beginning in 1983, many states began using triploid, sterilegrass carp as an alternative, because of their inability to reproduce,their longevity, and their voracious appetite. On the other hand, thisgenetically modified exotic species, if not used properly, can reduceor eliminate desirable plants and outcompete native fish, causing moredamage than good. The use of one exotic species to control otherexotic species has had a problematic history across the globe, generatingcontroversy and criticism. Newer methods for genetic modificationof organisms to achieve specific outcomes will certainly becomemore…arrow_forwardBackground Info Rainbow trout go through a unique genetic reproductive process. Female eggs are diploid, while male sperm are haploid. In the wild, when the sperm fertilizes an egg, the extra set of chromosomes is kicked out, resulting in a diploid offspring.Triploid trout are produced in the lab to provide sterile fish stock for lakes. Shortly after the eggs are fertilized, scientists place them in a warm water bath to prevent the extra chromosomes from being removed. The result is a triploid fish that cannot reproduce.Rainbow Trout: n = 30 Global warming is an issue affecting many species around the world. Warming has caused the temperatures in lakes and rivers to increase and stay elevated for longer periods of time. Question Select the FOUR numbers that describe the possible effects of global warming on the reproduction of rainbow trout in the wild and on biodiversity. The extra set of chromosomes remains. The extra set of chromosomes is removed. The offspring are diploid (2n).…arrow_forward
- Another gene in Drosophila determines wing length. The dominant wild-type allele of this gene produces long wings; a recessive allele produces vestigial (short) wings. A female that is true- breeding for red eyes and long wings is mated with a male that has purple eyes and vestigial wings. F1 females are then crossed with purple-eyed, vestigial-winged males. From this second cross, a total of 600 offspring are obtained with the following combinations of traits: 252 with red eyes and long wings 276 with purple eyes and vestigial wings 42 with red eyes and vestigial wings 30 with purple eyes and long wings Are the genes linked, unlinked, or sex-linked? If they are linked, how many map units separate them on the chromosome?arrow_forwardSome recessive alleles have such a detrimental effect that they are lethal when present in both chromosomes of a pair. Homozygous recessives cannot survive and die at some point during embryonic development. Suppose that the allele r is lethal in the homozygous rr condition. What genotypic ratios would you expect among the living offspring of the following crosses? a. RRRr b. RrRrarrow_forwardA heterozygous pea plant produces violet flowers and yellow, round seeds. Describe the expected genotypes of the gametes produced by Mendelian inheritance. If all three genes are found on the same arm of one chromosome should a scientist predict that inheritance patterns will follow Mendelian genetics?arrow_forward
- In sweet pea plants, an allele for purple flowers. (P) is dominanl when paired with a recessive allele for red flowers (p). An allele for Jang pollen grains (L) is dominant when paired with a recessive allele for round pollen grains (L). Bateson and Punnett crossed a plant having purple flowers and long pollen grains with one having white flowers and round pollen grains. All F1 offspring have purple flowers and long pollen grains. Among the F2 generation, the researchers observed the following phenotypes: 296 purple flowers/long pollen grains 19 purple /lower/ round pollen grains 27 red flowers/long pollen grains 85 red flowers/round pollen grains What is the best explanation for these results?arrow_forwardThe gene for flower position in pea plants exists as axial or terminal alleles. Given that axial is dominant to terminal, list all of the possible F1 and F2 genotypes and phenotypes from a cross involving parents that are homozygous for each trait. Express genotypes with conventional genetic abbreviations.arrow_forwardAssuming no gene linkage, in a dihybrid cross of AABB x aabb with AaBb F1 heterozygotes, what is the ratio of the F1 gametes (AB, aB, Ab, ab) that will give rise to the F2 offspring? a. 1:1:1:1 b. 1:3:3:1 c. 1:2:2:1 d. 4:3:3:1arrow_forward
- Biology: The Dynamic Science (MindTap Course List)BiologyISBN:9781305389892Author:Peter J. Russell, Paul E. Hertz, Beverly McMillanPublisher:Cengage LearningBiology: The Unity and Diversity of Life (MindTap...BiologyISBN:9781305073951Author:Cecie Starr, Ralph Taggart, Christine Evers, Lisa StarrPublisher:Cengage LearningBiology 2eBiologyISBN:9781947172517Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann ClarkPublisher:OpenStax