Case summary:
Contracted person R J. C. Surge Service, a temporary plumber company, to fix a halt along her house's sewer pipe. The "snake" gadget of the plumbing service, used to clear the line driving to the most drain, was trapped in the underground pipe. The firm excavated a portion of the sewer line into the terrace of Person R to drain it. The business finds this inside the handle various spills in a corroded, flawed water pipe that ran parallel with the sewer line. To follow open directions, it was appropriate to repair the water pipe, of a kind not endorsed for such benefit, either at that point or later, when the yard would be exhumed again. The plumbing company continued the repair of the water drain. While Richardson reviewed the day-to-day work of the company and voiced no concern at the additional work involved in the supplanting of the water pipe, she refused payment of any portion of the entire charge after the company completed the entire operation. J. C. Surge Company sued Person R
For the labour and fabric costs, it had outfitted.
To discuss: The reason if anything should person R be liable.
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solution- In a legal brief on negligence the following statement was made: "Where negligence can be established, it is no defense that the negligent action was in full compliance with all government regulations and permit conditions." Explain why this defense may not be valid.arrow_forwardHawkins slipped and fell on a puddle of water just inside the automatic door to the H. E. Butt Grocery Company’s store. The water had been tracked into the store by customers and blown through the door by a strong wind. The store manager was aware of the puddle and had mopped it up several times earlier in the day. Still, no signs had been placed to warn store patrons of the danger. Hawkins brought an action to recover damages for injuries sustained in the fall. Was the store negligent in its conduct?arrow_forwardNegligent in failing to give warning of the approach of its train to a crossing, CC Railroad thereby endangers Larry, a blind man who is about to cross. Mildred, a bystander, in a reasonable effort to save Larry, rushes onto the track to push Larry out of danger. Although Mildred acts as carefully as possible, she is struck and injured by the train. a. Can Mildred recover from Larry? b. Can Mildred recover from CC Railroad?arrow_forward
- National-Southwire Aluminum Company (NSA) owns and operates a plant that emits fluoride. When its wet scrubbers were turned off as part of its regular maintenance program, NSA discovered no appreciable change in ambient fluoride levels. Because of the expense of operating the scrubbers and its belief that using the scrubbers did not significantly affect ambient fluoride levels, NSA desired to turn the scrubbers off permanently. Accordingly, NSA sought a determination from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that turning off the scrubbers would not constitute a modification requiring the application of new source performance standards to the plant. Turning off the scrubbers would result in an increase of more than 1,100 tons per year of fluoride emissions with no decrease in the emission of any other pollutant. This increase was nearly four hundred times the level the EPA had established as inconsequential. The EPA determined that turning off the scrubbers would constitute a “new…arrow_forwardcharity takes her engagemnet ring to sparkles jewellery for cleaning and appraisal. she has to pay for the work when she picks up the ring. while the jeweler's back is turned and charity had left the building, someone slips behind the counter and steals a number of boxes containing repaired jewelry incluiding charity's ring. with reference to the above, highlight Sparkles liability and charity;s remedies if any.arrow_forwardJohn Brown Ales Pty Ltd sells bottled beer to select licensed premises. Mary is out with friends and consumes a bottle of John Brown’s Old-Fashioned Ale. When she gets to the bottom of the bottle, she realises that there are the remains of an insect in the bottle. Mary suffered shock and became very ill with gastroenteritis. Mary missed two days of work and needed medical attention. Can John Brown be brought to account for Mary’s costs and suffering?arrow_forward
- On March 17, Peckham bought a new car from Larsen Chevrolet for $16,400. During the first one and one-half months after the purchase, Peckham discovered that the car’s hood was dented, its gas tank contained no baffles, its emergency brake was inoperable, the car did not have a jack or a spare tire, and neither the clock nor the speedometer worked. Larsen claimed that Peckham knew of the defects at the time of the purchase. Peckham, on the other hand, claimed that he did not know the extent of the defects and that despite his repeated efforts the defects were not repaired until June 11. Then, on July 15, the car’s dashboard caught fire, leaving the car’s interior damaged and the car itself inoperable. Peckham then returned to Larsen Chevrolet and told Larsen that he had to repair the car at his own expense or that he, Peckham, would either rescind the contract or demand a new automobile. Peckham also claimed that at the end of their conversation he notified Larsen Chevrolet that he was…arrow_forwardIn 2012, Angela took out a $15,000 loan against the cash surrender value of her whole life insurance policy. The funds were required to help pay for remodeling and redecorating her home. As a consequences of taking out the loan Angela had to report $3,000 of policy gain in 2014. She repaid $5,000 of the loan at the end of 2015, as well as paying the $600 of loan interest due for the year. What were the tax consequences to Angela and the policy as a result of the 2015 payments? A. She will be able to deduct $5,600 from her taxable income for 2015 ad the ACB of the policy will increased by $2,000. B. She will be able to deduct $3,000 from her taxable income for 2015 and the ACB of the policy will increase by $2,600. C. She will not be able to claim any deduction from her taxable income for 2015 and the ACB of the policy will increase by $5,650. D. She will be able to deduct $3,600 from her taxable income for 2015 and the ACB of the policy will increase by $2,000arrow_forwardPilot Petroleum Associates, Inc., and various affiliated companies distributed gasoline to retail gasoline stations in the state of New York. Pilot owned some of these stations and leased them to individual operators who were under contract to purchase gasoline from Pilot. The EPA took samples of gasoline from five different service stations to which Pilot had sold unleaded gasoline. These samples showed that Pilot had delivered “unleaded gasoline that contained amounts of lead in excess of that permitted by the Clean Air Act and EPA regulations.” The United States brought criminal charges against Pilot for violating the act and EPA regulations and sought fines from Pilot. Who wins? Explain.arrow_forward
- A chemical processing company stored toxic waste on its premises. A severe storm caused damaged to the containers storing the waste, which resulted in the spill contaminating nearby pond, which belongs to Sam. The chemical processing company was careful when storing the waste and no allegation of negligence is made. However, Sam claims that the chemical processing company is liable for the pond contamination, even though there is no negligence. Is Sam correct? Explainarrow_forwardBarbara Rome entered Flower Memorial Hospital to undergo a series of X-rays. When she was ready for the X-rays, she was assisted by a student radiological intern. The intern placed Rome on the X-ray table and strapped her onto the table correctly; however, the intern did not properly fasten the footboard, which was located at the foot of the table. As a result of this error, Rome fell and was hurt when the table was raised. As a consequence, Rome brought a lawsuit against Flower Memorial Hospital, alleging that the ordinary negligence of the intern had caused her injury. In contrast, the hospital argued that the lawsuit involved a medical claim, as defined under the state’s medical malpractice statute. Whether a case involves ordinary negligence or a medical claim would determine whether the state’s two-year statute of limitations for negligence or the state’s one-year statute of limitations for medical claims would apply. This case clearly involves a difference of opinion on the…arrow_forwardDixie, a driver for Express Delivery Company, leaves the truck's motor running in neutral and carelessly forgets to set the parking brake while she makes a delivery. The truck rolls and crashes into a nearby gas station pump, igniting a fire that spreads quickly to a construction site a block away. A burned wall collapses onto a crane, which falls on Fazio, a bystander, and injures him. What must Fazio show to recover damages from Express Delivery?arrow_forward
- Understanding BusinessManagementISBN:9781259929434Author:William NickelsPublisher:McGraw-Hill EducationManagement (14th Edition)ManagementISBN:9780134527604Author:Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. CoulterPublisher:PEARSONSpreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract...ManagementISBN:9781305947412Author:Cliff RagsdalePublisher:Cengage Learning
- Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi...ManagementISBN:9780135191798Author:Kenneth C. Laudon, Jane P. LaudonPublisher:PEARSONBusiness Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in...ManagementISBN:9780134728391Author:Ronald J. Ebert, Ricky W. GriffinPublisher:PEARSONFundamentals of Management (10th Edition)ManagementISBN:9780134237473Author:Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter, David A. De CenzoPublisher:PEARSON