The SEC prohibits insider trading through the statutory provisions only when the monetary benefit is earned by the insider for himself. The SEC decided to amend the law and the action can be brought even when there is no monetary benefit to insiders. The commission did not follow the procedure of rulemaking and simply announced the law. An objection against the law was brought by a stock brokerage firm on the ground that the rule was made without giving any opportunity for public comments. The rule was ultimately challenged before the federal appellate court. To find: The effect of considering the rule merely as an interpretive rule.

Question

Want to see the full answer?

Answer 1

Question

Chapter 23, Problem 4RE

Summary Introduction

Case summary:The SEC prohibits insider trading through the statutory provisions only when the monetary benefit is earned by the insider for himself. The SEC decided to amend the law and the action can be brought even when there is no monetary benefit to insiders. The commission did not follow the procedure of rulemaking and simply announced the law. An objection against the law was brought by a stock brokerage firm on the ground that the rule was made without giving any opportunity for public comments. The rule was ultimately challenged before the federal appellate court.

To find: The effect of considering the rule merely as an interpretive rule.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Students have asked these similar questions

The “Compliance with Standards Rule” requires that a member who performs professional services, including consulting services, comply with standards promulgated by bodies designated by Council, regardless of whether the member is holding out as a CPA. The standards applicable to members performing consulting services are set forth in the Statements on Standards for Consulting Services (SSCSs) and specifically state that such standards apply to members holding out as a CPA while providing consulting services. Would a member who does not hold out as a CPA be in compliance with “Compliance with Standards Rule” if the member did not comply with the SSCSs while performing consulting services for a client? Yes or No

TRUE OR FALSE. Write True if the statement is true. Otherwise, write false.1. Business advertisement is a valid offer.2. Deaf-mutes have no capacity to give consent.3. Fraud voids a contract.4. If B gives his consent due to A’s threat of exposing his marital affairs, there will be nocontract because consent is vitiated.5 Exaggerations in trade are not fraudulent

Which of the following statements about the Securities Act of 1933 is not true?(1) The third-party user does not have the burden of proof that she/he relied on thefinancial statements.(2) The third party has the burden of proof that the auditor was either negligent orfraudulent in doing the audit.(3) The third-party user does not have the burden of proof that the loss was causedby the misleading financial statements.(4) The auditor will not be liable if he or she can demonstrate due diligence inperforming the audit.