EGR 2500 Lab1_report_grading F23

EGR 2500 – Fall 2023 Laboratory Assignment #1 Technical Content (90%) Report of Group #________ ______/10 A BSTRACT  Does the abstract state the principal objectives and scope of the lab assignment, describe the methods employed, summarize the important results, and state the principal conclusions?  Does it list the ranges of flowrate and uncertainty values for the experiment, as well as the discharge coefficient values obtained?  Does the abstract stand on its own (i.e., not reference figures, tables, equation numbers in the report)?  Is the organization logical, and understandable to a reader (from outside this course)? ______/5 D ATA C OLLECTION  Has the experiment been properly conducted and has the data been accurately gathered?  Was the correct procedure followed and was an adequate number of data points collected? ______/10 T HEORY  Are the indirect volume flowrate uncertainty and relative uncertainty equations properly derived? Is the derivation correct?  Are the final indirect flow rate uncertainty and relative uncertainty equations shown in symbolic form (not just numbers)?  Are the equations for the ideal and corrected venturi and orifice meter flow rates shown properly and expressed in terms of appropriate manometer heights?  Does the theory section include a schematic?  Does the theory section follow the required guidelines (figure, equation numbers, definition of variables, transition sentences, neat if handwritten, etc.)? ______/15 T ABULAR RESULTS  Are at least two tables shown (one for collected data and one for calculated data) and is all of the required data (including volume collection method uncertainty and relative uncertainty, venturi and orifice meter discharge coefficients and ideal/corrected flow rates, as well as % differences) shown?  Are there any errors in the data reduction (calculation errors)?  Has the data been clearly presented and can one easily relate data from one table to data in the other table(s) (e.g., by a common first column)?  Do the tables adhere to the required formatting guidelines (Table number, title, column labels, units, etc.)?  Was instrument uncertainty information properly reported? ______/20 G RAPHS  Are the required two graphs included (one with trendlines to determine the C d values and the other comparing the flow meter values to the volume collection method values) and plotted correctly?