Ethics Activity
Historically, diesel cars have not been big sellers in the U.S. auto market, mainly because their engines couldn't pass the strict emissions standards set up the Environmental Protection Agency and the California Air Resources Board. But that all changed in 2005, when German automaker Volkswagen make a decided push to develop "clean diesel" engines, specifically manufactured to meet strict U.S. emissions standards.
By 2010, VW had introduced several models of diesel cars in the United States, and their sales helped propel Volkswagen to the number two slot in global auto sales, after Toyota and ahead of GM. While VW was receiving major media attention for its clean diesel models, researchers from West Virginia University discovered that these so-called clean engines had been constructed with a "defeat device" −software that could actually tell when the car was being tested off road for emissions and lower the level of emissions that harm the environment.
By December 2014, Volkswagen agreed to voluntarily recall more than a half-million clean diesel cars in the United States to address the emissions issues. But the scandal continued to escalate, with accusations that senior management knew about the rigged engines, and VW's CEO resigned and several other executives were fired.
Class-action lawsuits and other litigation followed, and in April 2017, VW agreed to a $4.3 billion settlement, which included a criminal fine of $2.8 billion, as well as various buyback plans for the affected diesel cars. In addition, over the last several years, VW has experienced a significant decline in U.S. sales and it now trying to win back customers.
Using a web search tool, locate information about this topic, and then write responses to the following questions. Be sure to support your arguments and cite your sources.
Ethical Dilemma: How can VW ensure that its diesel now comply with U.S. emissions standards? What can VW do to regain consumers' confidence after this worldwide scandal? Do you agree with the billions of dollars in fines that VW will have to pay to move beyond the emissions debacle?
Source: "VW Diesel Crisis: Timeline of Events," https://www.cars.com, May 19, 2017; Jack Ewing, "Inside VW's Campaign of Trickery," The New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com, May 7, 2017; Christoph Rauwald, "How a Top-Secret Deal Could Have Stopped VW's Diesel Scandal." Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com, January 12, 2017; "6 VW Excecs Indicated as Carmaker Agrees to $4.3 Billion Diesel Cheat Settlement," Fortune, https://fortune.com, January 12, 2017; Geoffrey Smith and Roger Parloff, "Hoaxwagen: Inside Volkswagen's Diesel Fraud," Fortune, https://fortune.com, March 7, 2016.
To explain:
The way company can ensure that the cars comply with the emission standards of the U.S. The way company can regain the confidence of consumers after this scandal and whether the amount of fine is justified.
Introduction:
The concept of ethics stands in between the two extremes of codified law and personal freedom. It refers to what is considered to be as correct behavior based on the societies interpretation. When the society interprets things differently, what was once the standard for ethics can change over time, for example, slavery in the 18th century or smoking in the 19th century.
Explanation of Solution
VW has always been a trusted brand in vehicle manufacturing. They have positioned themselves as company that is in the forefront of European vehicle manufacturing with superior technology and luxury through reputed brands.
However, there is no doubt that they broke the law and were highly unethical in their practices which forced the customers to move away from the brand. Even though VW has admitted to the wrong doing and has paid fines of billions of dollars they are yet to fix the problem of customer trust. In the minds of the customer, VW is a company that has rigged regulatory bodies to gain sale advantages.
There are several things that VW can do to regain customer trust. Firstly, they must be open about what took place in the organization through an unbiased investigation and make those details available for the public. Secondly, they can obtain 3rd party certifications about the emission results and prove that they are not harmful. Finally,they can invest in CSR activities that amends the image of VW by showing that they care about the environment and the society and not just the bottom line.
The fines imposed on VW is a first step in bring the organization on track. However 4.8 billion dollars is not a major loss for a company like VW. Therefore, there should be more strict legal action such as criminal charges against executives involved, regulatory scrutiny on VW activity and embargos to send out a stronger message.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 1 Solutions
Introduction to Business
Additional Business Textbook Solutions
Principles of Management
Cost Accounting (15th Edition)
Horngren's Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis (16th Edition)
Managerial Accounting (4th Edition)
Principles of Accounting Volume 1
Horngren's Accounting (11th Edition)
- In the summer of 2017, Transport of London (TfL) began proceedings to revoke Ubers permit to operate in London. How do think Ubers poor corporate reputation may have been a factor in TfLs thinking?arrow_forwardwhat is the message of "We are the World" 2020-Covid 19 Tribure -the Quarantine Mix -Long Island version.arrow_forwardWhat responsibility does the regulator EPA has in the Volkswagen emission scandal? To what extent can blame be put on the EPA?arrow_forward
- 1. A bank serves customers who require personal loans; As part of its processes, it asks applicants to open an account to make their periodic installments. In its range of services it offers auto insurance, credit and debit cards. The adviser asks each of the clients to sign an insurance policy, making them believe that it is mandatory, behind the back of the company. a. Describe the consequences for the bank of the executive's attitude. b. It lists the actions that would be omitted according to the OECD code of best practices. c. Propose actions to be taken to mitigate these risks, and define who is in charge of implementing and monitoring them. d. Mention 3 continuous improvement activities.arrow_forwardScenario 1: Receiving GiftsYou are the Director of Contracts at the Ministry of Energy. During theChristmas season, one of the Oil and Gas Companies sent a hamperof expensive goodies personally addressed to you at the office. Whatactions might you want to take? Consider the alternatives you have available to you and how they affect the stakeholders. What are the consequences, duties, rights, and principles, implications for personal integrity and character?arrow_forwardCase Study In 1901, the newly created Commonwealth of Europe established the Postmaster- General’s Department to handle all post and telephone within this vast country. At that time, telephone systems were regarded as a natural monopoly, and in many countries the systems were government-owned and operated. In 1991, though, the telephone system was hived off as a separate company, trading as ABC, but still wholly owned by the European government. In common with most other industrialized countries, European government thinking underwent some radical changes during the early 1990s. Most governments around this time were looking for ways of liberalizing their nationalized industries – in many cases governments also saw the opportunity to generate some income by selling off nationalized industries to private investors. Greater competition and the action of market forces were seen as the way forward, and even the former so-called ‘natural monopolies’ such as railways, telephone…arrow_forward
- Case Study In 1901, the newly created Commonwealth of Europe established the Postmaster- General’s Department to handle all post and telephone within this vast country. At that time, telephone systems were regarded as a natural monopoly, and in many countries the systems were government-owned and operated. In 1991, though, the telephone system was hived off as a separate company, trading as ABC, but still wholly owned by the European government. In common with most other industrialized countries, European government thinking underwent some radical changes during the early 1990s. Most governments around this time were looking for ways of liberalizing their nationalized industries – in many cases governments also saw the opportunity to generate some income by selling off nationalized industries to private investors. Greater competition and the action of market forces were seen as the way forward, and even the former so-called ‘natural monopolies’ such as railways, telephone…arrow_forwardTo be included in the EMAS scheme, organisations shall carry out an initial environmental review as outlined in the annex: Select one: a. II. b. III. c. I.arrow_forwardEthics, corporate social responsibility and sustainability: 'Business- Volkswagen Group' i. Review the CSR and Sustainability policies of the business. Using relevant models and concepts, like AB Carroll’s, examine the level of ethics and CSR displayed by this company. (Make sure you look for news stories aboutthis business and the CEO). ii. Does the business live up to their vision and values? iii. Do you consider this company as “ethical”? To what extent? Justify your answer. iv. What recommendations can you offer to improve the reputation and image of this organisation? If you believe this company is in fact ethical, analyse and explain the impact its values have. What can other businesses learn from this company?arrow_forward
- Most codes of corporate governance, boards and committees, including Committee of Sponsoring Organisations (COSO) (2004), Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Basel III, Solvency II and King IV Report on Governance, emphasise that riskmanagement is indispensable. Nonetheless traditional risk management alone appears to leave out some important aspects which led to the development of Enterprise Risk Management.Compare and contrast traditional risk management with enterprise risk management. Include the eight components of enterprise risk management from the Committee of Sponsoring Organisations (COSO) framework in your discussion. (30 marks.arrow_forwardMost codes of corporate governance, boards and committees, including Committee of Sponsoring Organisations (COSO) (2004), Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Basel III, Solvency II and King IV Report on Governance, emphasise that riskmanagement is indispensable. Nonetheless traditional risk management alone appears to leave out some important aspects which led to the development of Enterprise Risk Management.Compare and contrast traditional risk management with enterprise risk management. Include the eight components of enterprise risk management from the Committee of Sponsoring Organisations (COSO) framework in your discussion.arrow_forwardsubject: international business how would you define ethics? *i need this asap, please help! thank youarrow_forward
Purchasing and Supply Chain ManagementOperations ManagementISBN:9781285869681Author:Robert M. Monczka, Robert B. Handfield, Larry C. Giunipero, James L. PattersonPublisher:Cengage Learning