Case summary:
In 1969, at the age of seventeen, Person A began working for company P. She had reached the rank of a bookkeeper, chief of office and right-hand treasurer by 2007. The board of chiefs of company P, in recognition of their capacity, dedication, and long service time, agreed to increase the month-to-month salary of Individual A to $4,000 and make a retirement plan. The agreement allowed person A to be granted the privilege of withdrawing from the complex contract if she wished to accept a retirement payment of $2,000 per month for life, even though the board expressed in faith that Person A would continue to represent the organization for a long time. Person A, as it may be, agreed to resign two a long time later. Company F has paid her retirement pay to Person A until 2016. The business suspended instalments from that point on.
To discuss: The arguments that the company’s promise to pay person A $2,000 per month for life is enforceable.
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 12 Solutions
Smith and Roberson’s Business Law
- Dennis and Donna Smith owned a 10-acre tract of land that they decided to sell. The couple entered into a listing agreement with Kelly McLaughlin, a licensed real estate broker. The agreement gave Kelly the exclusive right to sell the property for a period of 6 months. The Smiths agreed to pay Kelly a 6% commission of the selling price if a buyer was found during the listing period. Four months later, the Smiths sent Kelly a letter terminating the listing agreement. Kelly did not approve of the conditions. One month later, Kelly presented a full price offer to the Smiths; however, they ignored the offer and sold the property to another buyer. Kelly sued the Smiths for breach of the agency agreement. Which party wins the lawsuit? Did the Smiths act ethically in this case?arrow_forwardSam Simpleton, a resident of Kansas, and Nellie Naive, a resident of Missouri, each bought $85,000 in stock at local offices in their home States from Evil Stockbrokers, Inc. (“Evil”), a business incorporated in Delaware, with its principal place of business in Kansas. Both Simpleton and Naive believe that they were cheated by Evil Stockbrokers and would like to sue Evil for fraud. Assuming that no Federal question is at issue, assess the accuracy of the following statements: a. Simpleton can sue Evil in a Kansas State trial court. b. Simpleton can sue Evil in a Federal district court in Kansas. c. Naive can sue Evil in a Missouri State trial court. d. Naive can sue Evil in a Federal district court in Missouri.arrow_forward• Effective April 21, 2014, Philip Luis F. Marin (Marin, for short) was appointed Reservations Officer of Cathay Pacific Aiways Ltd (Cathay) for a probationary period of six months. A letter dated March 23, 2014 was given to him specitying his appointment wherein he is to receive a monthly salary including holidays and rest days, with a promise of a salary review upon satisfactory completion of the probationary period. The letter also stated that Cathay reserved the right to terminate (Marin) services during the probationary period if performance proves to be unsatisfactory, in which case will receive the salary due at the time of the termination of his services. Mr. Marin accepted those terms of employment and that he would be reconfirmed asa member of regular staff upon completion of the probationary period. Mr. Marin was briefed and counseled by virtue of a Memorandum which was released by M.A. Canizares (Administrative Supervisor) dated October 15, 2013. It was noted that Mr. Marin…arrow_forward
- Columbia University brought suit against Jacobsen on two notes signed by him and his parents. The notes represented the balance of tuition he owed the University. Jacobsen counterclaimed for money damages due to Columbia’s deceit or fraudulent misrepresentation. Jacobsen argues that Columbia fraudulently misrepresented that it would teach wisdom, truth, character, enlightenment, and similar virtues and qualities. He specifically cites as support the Columbia motto: “in lumine tuo videbimus lumen” (“In your light we shall see light”); the inscription over the college chapel: “Wisdom dwelleth in the heart of him that hath understanding”; and various excerpts from its brochures, catalogues, and a convocation address made by the University’s president. Jacobsen, a senior who was not graduated because of poor scholastic standing, claims that the University’s failure to meet its promises made through these quotations constituted fraudulent misrepresentation or deceit. Decision?arrow_forwardGreen was the owner of a large department store. On Wednesday, January 26, he talked to Smith and said, “I will hire you as sales manager in my store for one year at a salary of $48,000; you are to begin work next Monday.” Smith accepted and started work on Monday, January 31. At the end of three months, Green discharged Smith. On May 15, Smith brings an action against Green to recover the unpaid portion of the $28,000 salary. Is Smith’s employment contract enforceable? Explain.arrow_forwardZenith Steel Company operates a prosperous business. In January, Zenith’s chief executive officer (CEO) and president, Roe, who is also a member of the board, was voted a $1 million bonus by the board of directors for the valuable services he provided to the company during the previous year. Roe receives an annual salary of $850,000 from the company. Black, Inc., a minority shareholder in Zenith Steel Company, brings an appropriate action to enjoin the company from paying the $1 million bonus. Explain whether Black will succeed in its attempt.arrow_forward
- David Rampersad has refused to be vaccinated due to religious reasons and has been informed that as he is a Plant Operator, the only vacancy is in Finance which is unsuitable for him, Accordingly, his employment has been terminated. There is nothing in the contract of David that included a requirement of vaccination for any diseases whatsoever. Please advise David.arrow_forwardState whether the following agreements or contracts are void, voidable valid, and provide a reason for your answer. 1 ) Taylor, aged 17, gets married, and divorces two months later. After getting divorced, she enters into a contract with Michael for the sale of his house. ( 2 ) Jessica, aged 5, enters into a contract with John, aged 11, for the sale of his bicycle. 3 ) Nomsa, aged 16, runs a successful boutique with the consent of her parents, and enters into a contract relating to her business. 4 ) Amy, who is 17, has inherited an apartment in Cape Town from her deceased father. The apartment is valued at R2 million. With her mother’s assistance, Amy enters into an agreement to sell the apartment to her aunt. 5 ) Justin, who is mentally ill, concludes a contract for the sale of his laptop without his curator knowing. (2)arrow_forward1. Roy asked Mark if he can use his phone for a week. If Roy agreed and allowed Mark to use his phone, what contract is created? Explain 2. Lance borrowed money from Renz. There was no stipulation to pay interest. Has Renz the right to demand interest? Explainarrow_forward
- Bakar is a renowned pastry Mama Cafe, a sole proprietorship, is a well-known restaurant in need of hiring a pastry chef. Bakar and Cafe’s Owner had extensive conversations regarding Bakar coming to work at Cafe. On May 1, a week after those conversations occurred, Bakar sent Cafe a signed letter dated May 1 stating, “I will work for Cafe as a head pastry chef for two years for an annual salary of RM50,000.” On the morning of May 7, Cafe’s Owner telephoned Bakar and said, “The RM50,000 is pretty stiff. Could you possibly consider working for less”? Bakar replied: “I am a renowned pastry chef. I will not work for any less.” Later that morning, Cafe’s Owner sent Bakar a signed letter by regular mail stating: “You obviously think you are too good for my restaurant. I am no longer interested in hiring you to work at Cafe.” Later that afternoon, Cafe’s Owner had a change of heart and sent Bakar a registered, express-mail signed letter stating: “Okay, if you really won’t work for less, I…arrow_forwardBakar is a renowned pastry Mama Cafe, a sole proprietorship, is a well-known restaurant in need of hiring a pastry chef. Bakar and Cafe’s Owner had extensive conversations regarding Bakar coming to work at Cafe. On May 1, a week after those conversations occurred, Bakar sent Cafe a signed letter dated May 1 stating, “I will work for Cafe as a head pastry chef for two years for an annual salary of RM50,000.” On the morning of May 7, Cafe’s Owner telephoned Bakar and said, “The RM50,000 is pretty stiff. Could you possibly consider working for less”? Bakar replied: “I am a renowned pastry chef. I will not work for any less.” Later that morning, Cafe’s Owner sent Bakar a signed letter by regular mail stating: “You obviously think you are too good for my restaurant. I am no longer interested in hiring you to work at Cafe.” Later that afternoon, Cafe’s Owner had a change of heart and sent Bakar a registered, express-mail signed letter stating: “Okay, if you really won’t work for less, I…arrow_forwardBakar is a renowned pastry Mama Cafe, a sole proprietorship, is a well-known restaurant in need of hiring a pastry chef. Bakar and Cafe’s Owner had extensive conversations regarding Bakar coming to work at Cafe. On May 1, a week after those conversations occurred, Bakar sent Cafe a signed letter dated May 1 stating, “I will work for Cafe as a head pastry chef for two years for an annual salary of RM50,000.” On the morning of May 7, Cafe’s Owner telephoned Bakar and said, “The RM50,000 is pretty stiff. Could you possibly consider working for less”? Bakar replied: “I am a renowned pastry chef. I will not work for any less.” Later that morning, Cafe’s Owner sent Bakar a signed letter by regular mail stating: “You obviously think you are too good for my restaurant. I am no longer interested in hiring you to work at Cafe.” Later that afternoon, Cafe’s Owner had a change of heart and sent Bakar a registered, express-mail signed letter stating: “Okay, if you really won’t work for less, I…arrow_forward
- Understanding BusinessManagementISBN:9781259929434Author:William NickelsPublisher:McGraw-Hill EducationManagement (14th Edition)ManagementISBN:9780134527604Author:Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. CoulterPublisher:PEARSONSpreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract...ManagementISBN:9781305947412Author:Cliff RagsdalePublisher:Cengage Learning
- Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi...ManagementISBN:9780135191798Author:Kenneth C. Laudon, Jane P. LaudonPublisher:PEARSONBusiness Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in...ManagementISBN:9780134728391Author:Ronald J. Ebert, Ricky W. GriffinPublisher:PEARSONFundamentals of Management (10th Edition)ManagementISBN:9780134237473Author:Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter, David A. De CenzoPublisher:PEARSON